News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by eru on Friday September 24, 2010 @12:18AM (#1722642)
Thanks for the information about the Swedish system.

> Sweden does not have electronic voting, and you can vote for anything [...]

That's not very connected. You could easily imagine a free form electronic system. And the German system on the other hand is (or used to be?) completely paper based: You got a ballot with the names of all the parties / candidates, and placed a tick next to the name you liked. Any writing made the ballot invalid.

Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by henrikschroder on Friday September 24, 2010 @05:56AM (#1723211)
> That's not very connected. You could easily imagine a free form electronic system.

I can also imagine a multitude of ways electronic voting can fail or be manipulated without anyone knowing.

Voter turnout was over 84%, and that number has been increasing over the last few elections. We do not have an accessibility problem. For the type of elections we have, the current system is a good fit. One person - one envelope. When the polling stations close the polling clerks take all the envelopes, open them, sort the ballots into valid and invalid piles, and then count the valid votes by hand. It takes a few hours, but we get a pretty accurate preliminary result on election night, and the process is completely open, anyone can watch the counting.

After the preliminary counting all the ballots are sent in to the regional election authority office where they do a second counting where they also add in mail-in votes from Swedes abroad and other people who couldn't be there on the voting day. The second counting is also completely open, anyone can come and watch.

Yes, it takes a few days to get the final result, but the confidence in the result is very high. Yes, there are occasional screwups, but it gets noticed, it gets reported, anyone can notice them, you don't need to a software engineer to have a chance at it.

Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by eru on Friday September 24, 2010 @09:02AM (#1723478)
Sure. I am not a fan of electronic voting either. Paper based voting is fine, because anyone can understand and audit it in principle. Auditing electronic voting is at least as hard as debugging.

If the general population can understand the inner workings of democracy, they are probably much more likely to embrace it.

(Though still, electronic voting and free form ballots are completely unconnected.)

Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by henrikschroder on Friday September 24, 2010 @09:40AM (#1723577)
Oh, you mean connected as in having with each other to do, not as in having the results connected to some central authority for quick counting. Sorry, I misunderstood you. :-)
Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by eru on Friday September 24, 2010 @10:18AM (#1723693)
I guess we had a violent agreement.
Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by Tsher-Man on Friday September 24, 2010 @01:47PM (#1724532)
Bull. Those German ballots may come with names on them, but you can also strike out names and add other names by hand. There may be individual restrictions on whether you can only name people that registered as candidates, or anyone fulfilling the legal requirements for being a candidate, but writing a name on a ballot doesn't always make it invalid (of course, if you write something else than a name - say, a story or an insult, or of you draw faces or doodle on it, it does become invalid).
Re:Did Little Bobby Tables migrate to Sweden? by eru on Friday September 24, 2010 @02:42PM (#1724829)
OK. My version was the cautious story, if you want to make sure your vote counts. I never bothered testing the limits back home --- also you do not really get feedback, your vote will be just silently discarded or counted.

By the way the Bundeswahlgesetz (Paragraph 39, Absatz 1) says: "Ungültig sind Stimmen, wenn der Stimmzettel [...] einen Zusatz oder Vorbehalt enthält."

So in general, putting extra stuff besides your tick, is not allowed.