News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by avip on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:17AM (#17225600)
I’m working in proximate space. Every research paper about nutrition in general and gut bacteria specifically should be assumed shit science.
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by gm-conspiracy on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:07AM (#17225866)
I see what you did there.
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by 3eto on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:28AM (#17225662)
Interested in learning more if you have time to expand. Cheers
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by avip on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:09AM (#17226257)
Sure. I see 3 recurring issues with "nutritional research" I'm exposed to:

1. Wayyyyy too much industry involvement, much of it not properly disclosed (OP here is a classical and representative example).

2. Lots of research from relatively small and "less known" institutes, done by researchers with hard to verify credentials.

3. Low scientific standards. That'd include:

  - Refusal to share data
  - Refusal to share data analysis methods
  - Not keeping the basics of a double-blinded test
  - No reproduction, and not even the possibility of independent reproducibility, as the methods are described so vaguely.
That's in a nutshell.
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by nonbel on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:54AM (#17227238)
This sounds like standard biomed to me:

  - Refusal to share data
  - Refusal to share data analysis methods
  - Not keeping the basics of a double-blinded test
  - No reproduction, and not even the possibility of independent reproducibility, as the methods are described so vaguely.
Can you link to a recent paper that doesnt run afoul of at least one of your criteria. Especially the last...
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by ianai on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:44AM (#17226468)
You identified the problem. What’s the solution?
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by neuronic on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:50AM (#17226506)
The solution is identification of bad methods and subsequent ignorance.

If only we had a metric for credible science that takes authors, institutions, publisher and funding sources into account....

Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by betageek on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:58AM (#17227258)
This seems like a great idea - is there some reason this doesn't exist?
Re:Secret to longevity may lie in the microbiome and the gut by ianai on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:25AM (#17228008)
Something that takes only authors, publishers, and institutions into account sounds counterproductive.

I think it’d be better to have an agreement that only reporducible papers are credible. Ie data the paper is reported on (to include “cleaned” data) and any tools developed (software tools) must always be included. As well as funding for everything disclosed.

Ultimately though I think we may just be seeing the obsolescence of current statistical theory. Science needs hypotheses to be testable in “trustable” metrics. But there are too many loop holes if things like p-hacking are possible.