News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by brian_herman on Saturday June 02, 2018 @11:38AM (#17214997)
Why are they changing?
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by lowry on Saturday June 02, 2018 @11:48AM (#17215041)
Because Speck is said to be more performant than AES.This is discussed in the mail.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by mtgx on Saturday June 02, 2018 @02:17PM (#17215671)
Why not use ChaCha20? I believe it's twice as fast, at least in software.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by dfox on Saturday June 02, 2018 @03:24PM (#17215948)
Because ChaCha20's block migh not even fit into memory on platforms that is Speck/Simon meant for. The question should be: Why not use XTEA or RC5/6.

And the answer (ignoring the NSA and it's opaqueness) is that Speck (in its reference implementation form) is slightly faster than both XTEA and RC5 and can be trivially implemented such that it is twice as fast and also uses 64b words in 128b block size variants which on typical 64b platforms leads to another essentially free 2x speedup. (Not that it makes sense to use Speck for bulk encryption on typical 64b CPU)

On the other hand team related to DJB published algorithm called Gimli (https://gimli.cr.yp.to/) whis is essentially narrower ChaCha 20 transformation with intentionally slow diffusion as to fit onto registers of register-constrained CPUs (like Thumb) that is intended as Keccak-style sponge permutation. On the other hand in my opinion authors' paper and slides also have similar issue as what part of the original article criticizes NSA for, the security arguments for Gimli are considerably better than NSA's arguably non-existent ones but then the bigest issue I intuitively have with Speck is slow (and somewhat one-way) diffussion of the key schedule and Gimli's 4-round function is somewhat similar or even worse in this manner (although it does not have the "onewayness", for lack of a better word).

Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by ciphergoth on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @11:55AM (#17238870)
We need a drop-in replacement for AES, and Gimli doesn't have a 128-bit block size.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by ciphergoth on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @11:53AM (#17238851)
See ebiggers' comment above - ChaCha20 isn't on its own suitable for disk encryption. We need something that is a drop-in replacement for AES to use in XTS mode.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by tptacek on Saturday June 02, 2018 @02:43PM (#17215777)
They're not. These are "lightweight" ciphers intended for embedded applications with very little processing power and memory for program code; they're for applications where AES wouldn't be workable.
Re:Linux Cryptography: Speck's real standing with the academ... by api on Saturday June 02, 2018 @12:20PM (#17215196)
They are not. These ciphers were rejected. AES is fine and we have great alternatives like Salsa/ChaCha too.