Re:Ask HN: Why golang doesn't have ternary operator?
by thamizhan2611 on Saturday June 02, 2018 @03:54AM
(#17213369)
I agree, when the logic is very complicated to be represented in a line of code.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Why golang doesn't have ternary operator?
by pcvarmint on Saturday June 02, 2018 @04:42AM
(#17213543)
(I use "conditional expression" in place of "ternary operator" here.)
I have no idea why GoLang doesn't have conditional expressions.
I find a conditional expression to be much easier to parse than if-else statements.
If it's too hard to read, then why is LISP written almost totally as expressions, and is still considered viable?
a ? b ? c : d : e
is much easier for me to read and understand than if (a) {
if (b) {
r = c;
} else {
r = d;
}
} else {
r = e;
}
GoLang is supposed to be designed to remove "boilerplate code" and reduce code size, so I don't know why it doesn't have conditional expressions.Without conditional expressions, C++11 (but not C++14 and later) constexpr functions wouldn't be Turing-complete.
Re:Ask HN: Why golang doesn't have ternary operator?
by kazinator on Saturday June 02, 2018 @10:07AM
(#17214635)
Lisp is unambiguous, whereas:
x = a ? b : c;
Oops; that assigns x = a, and tests it. Not if that = is that of an initializer, though: int x = a ? : b : c;
so now we have an expression that changes meaning if we have to split the initialization off into an assignment.You're often better off if you put it behind a macro:
#define IF(X, Y, Z) ((X) ? (Y) : (Z))
In C coding, a lot of ternary action happens behind the curtain of preprocessing, where expression is almost fully parenthesized.