The further to the right a voting method is, the more it "maximizes happiness" for the voters
Why should group satisfaction with the winner be the important metric? Surely good governance should be the most important metric. If the quality of government is too hard to measure then length of time before overthrow or revolution should be a good proxy.
Markets are supposed to be efficient they match demand with production efficiently, or some such. Political demand needs to be matched with equal efficiency. Imposing good governance into a voting system will very likely create distortions.
The purpose of elections is not to be happy with the outcome of the election, it's to be happy with the policy that results from the election.
If closer to personal preference is better, shouldn't direct democracy - absolute majority rule - be the ideal? But it's clearly not the case, at least not in any sizeable country.
If welfare helps people in the short term, but reinforces cycles of poverty is that good for the country or not?
If nationalized medicine helps people in the short term, but eliminates the incentive for medical innovation is that good or bad?
It's almost like this is a really complicated problem that the best and brightest have been thinking about for centuries.
This interactive graph predicting outcomes for different voting methods convinced me that this is much harder to do than it would seem. Very much worth checking out the link. I think maybe I found it on HN.