News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by trothamel on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:00AM (#17205857)
If you want to fix politics in the US, bring back earmarks.

It sounds like I'm advocating corruption, and I kind of am. But at the same time, earmarks served the purpose of providing a good reason for parties to work together, across the aisle. If a little bit of corruption accomplishes that higher purpose, I'm glad to have it.

Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by snowwrestler on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:48AM (#17206464)
Earmarks are orthogonal to corruption. An earmark simply allocates money to a specific project; a member of Congress who steers money to their district is not "corrupt," he or she is just looking out for the citizens they represent--which BTW is their job.

An earmark is only corrupt if it is bought--that is, if a citizen or company bribes the member of Congress to steer an earmark to them.

When earmarks were killed, there was actually little evidence that was happening. Earmarks were killed as a talking point about reducing spending. Which is silly, because earmarks allocated funds, they didn't appropriate them. That is, they typically divvied up the pot, not increased its size.

It's sort of like the debt limit. Politicians lie to people about things work, in order to attract votes. I don't know if that's corruption so much as cynical opportunism.

Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by TooBrokeToBeg on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:05PM (#17208206)
> Earmarks are orthogonal to corruption.

Only in theory. In practice, they are 1:1 - You initiate pork A here, I help you add pork B there. You own pork B company, I own pork A. We both win money, forget the constituents.

Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by trothamel on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:15PM (#17206825)
That's fair enough. Maybe stupid is a better word than corrupt. The "bridge to nowhere", grants for absurd causes, that kind of thing. They might seem stupid, but if they would allow a fix to Obamacare to pass (say, smoothing out rough edges, rather than a repeal or nothing) then the bridge is just a monument to getting things done.
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by michaelbuckbee on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:41AM (#17206366)
A slight counterpoint: earmarks are correlated to a time when there were less strict party lines, so you did have people in office who were more moderate politically.

How about less gerrymandering? It results in more extreme candidates on both sides (as you get much more "pure" blue/red districts and fewer purple).

Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by trothamel on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:18PM (#17206854)
I'd argume that's true, but that earmarks are part of the cause of the less strict party lines. "Sure, I might be moderate. But you can be sure that year in and year out, I can bring West Eastport the bacon."
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by ballenarosada on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:07AM (#17205967)
why would bipartisanship be good?
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by castlecrasher2 on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:20AM (#17206109)
Are you saying it's bad?
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by ams6110 on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:37AM (#17206318)
If someothing can't be seen as worthwhile by both sides, without payoffs, there's probably a strong argument for not doing it. Gridlock is generally a good thing at the Federal level.
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by ajross on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:07PM (#17206715)
What happens, then, when one "side" takes it as an article of faith that any plan proposed by the other side needs to be rejected out of hand? That's the circumstance we're in right now, and have been since 2008 at least.

To wit, Merrick Garland would like a word.

Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by snowwrestler on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:59AM (#17206626)
This is fine as a theoretical construct, but the reality is that a lot of the best features of American government were the result of quid pro quo deal-making. A huge example is the entire Bill of Rights, which was the price of creating a stronger central government. And the movie "Lincoln" illustrates (with only a little exaggeration) the deal-making that went into passing the 13th Amendment.

As an aside, I happen to think that there is an important difference between "bipartisan" and "deal-making," and the latter is really where it's at in governance. Earmarks are tools for deal-making.

Framing things as "both sides" inappropriately elevates the 2 major political parties as a central feature of our system of government. They're not; in fact the largest political affiliation in the U.S. today is "indepdendent"!

And on any serious legislation, there are typically more than two "sides" with an interest in a particular outcome. That's why making deals is so important.

Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by kadenshep on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:44AM (#17206411)
Why do these discussions always assume rational or good faith actors, when that so obviously isn't the case?
Re:Politics is bad because we use an 18th century voting system by ballenarosada on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:49PM (#17207246)
No, just asking why it would be good. The claim was that it's so good that it's worth increased corruption.