Batteries and hydro can both break 90% round trip efficiency while having very low costs. To win something needs to be better than that or very cheap, and burring stuff is not cheap.
The problem is stockpiling. If we have a lot of solar, we will need to stockpile energy in the summer for the winter.
Buying a giant battery that charges in the summer so I can run an electric heater in the winter is probably more expensive than figuring out how to manufacture a flammable gas. If I use it for 20 years, and take into account the energy used to manufacture, I wonder what the "true" efficiency is?
It's still very affordable to heat with wood, (which captures CO2 from the air,) so I'm rather confident we can figure out how to do this at scale.
Also with solar + wind their is no need for seasonal storage just have extra capacity and move it from other areas. 30-50% daily grid storage is about the useful limit above that and you're better off with more capacity.
PS: It's a different story if you say live on an island above the attic circle, but that's not a huge market.
Historically, steam turbine plants get retrofitted to run on different fuels. I think there's a good chance we'll figure out how to stockpile a flammable gas from solar energy, and then retrofit these kinds of plants to use it.
In this particular case, capturing CO2 is interesting, because stockpiling solar energy to a flammable gas may require a source of pure CO2. Thus, this plant could stockpile CO2 in the winter when sunlight is less abundant, and then stockpile fuel in the summer when sunlight is more abundant.