News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by mirimir on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:41PM (#17202419)
That's a very complicated way to generate electricity from methane. But why do we want to do that? Isn't it better to get our electricity from PV, and reserve methane as a chemical feedstock?
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by adventured on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:07AM (#17202497)
No. We should very aggressively pursue the use of natural gas until all coal plants are shuttered. Then we move on to dealing with natural gas after that. Anything that makes natural gas better in the meantime, is a plus to the process.

China for one example is getting an extraordinary amount of their electricity from coal. They're consuming more coal than the rest of the world combined. You are largely not going to be able to fully replace that with PV in the next 20-30 years. It can potentially be replaced with natural gas, nuclear and a combination of traditional renewables.

The US is in the same boat, albeit with a much lower level of coal consumption and a vast domestic supply of natural gas. All coal plants should be shut down in the US by continuing to transition to natural gas, while we keep building a lot of wind and solar, and at least maintaining our nuclear output (ideally we'd double that, but...).

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by donarb on Friday June 01, 2018 @11:47AM (#17206448)
> We should very aggressively pursue the use of natural gas until all coal plants are shuttered.

The administration is now proposing that grid operators be forced to buy electricity from coal and nuclear plants that are now in the process of being shut down. The excuse is "national security".

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-01/trump-sai...

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by mirimir on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:29AM (#17202562)
OK, I get that. Methane, even without CO2 capture, is better than coal.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by manicdee on Friday June 01, 2018 @01:04AM (#17202736)
Yes. The comparisons of CO2 output aside, methane mining is increasingly being shown to be a major contributor to methane in the atmosphere. Being a far more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide, we need to minimise the production of methane, rather than increase it. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/oct/26/what-is-...

As far as renewables go we have options including wind power which are already cheaper than natural gas plant: https://cleantechnica.com/2016/12/25/cost-of-solar-power-vs-...

So both from economic and ecological viewpoints, natural gas is a bad idea.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by throwahey on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:06AM (#17204505)
Consider me ignorant in this topic, but doesn't coal throughput beat out Solar or Wind? As far as I know you can always burn coal where as wind and solar are limited by external factors.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by manicdee on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:50PM (#17223875)
A 100% renewable grid is possible by over-deploying renewable capacity, and providing time of production and time of use smoothing through storage.

Solar is particularly good at addressing daily peaks because those peaks generally happen during the day. Wind is good at relatively steady production around the clock because there is almost always wind blowing somewhere.

Coal is pretty terrible because it takes hours to react to changes in demand. This is why we have the term “baseload”: the rest of the industry must be highly dispachable to work around the high thermal mass (and resultant low responsiveness) of coal plants.

In addition coal plant tends to be large monolithic production, so the loss of one plant represents a significant proportion of supply. Coal is thus a net hazard to power reliability.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by Baeocystin on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:57PM (#17210204)
You don't deserve to be downvoted for your statement, as it is correct- coal plants can function 34/7, unlike most other green sources other than geothermal.

Of course, gas plants can also function continuously, and for baseline, nothing beats nuclear. But burning gas for energy is far better than just releasing it unburned in to the air, or flaring it for no productive purpose.

As we get more large-scale batteries online, the variable output of things like wind and solar will matter less, and they will be able to provide an ever-increasing percentage of our energy mix. This is well underway, but it is a huge task that will take a long time to complete.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by __s on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:34AM (#17204669)
Renewables which have jitter in their throughput can be made consistent with batteries

https://thinkprogress.org/colorado-wind-batteries-cheap-12e8...

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by manicdee on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:35PM (#17223799)
There are also pumped hydro and flywheels, amongst other options for storage with various optimum characteristics.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by mirimir on Friday June 01, 2018 @01:10AM (#17202759)
But still better overall than coal, perhaps?
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by manicdee on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:15AM (#17202990)
If you are switching away from coal, the economically sensible decision is renewables. The ecologically sensible decision is also renewables.

Switching to gas is just trading one version of disaster for another. Instead of your world being razed by Godzilla you spend lots of money so it gets razed by Hedorah instead.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by adrianN on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:00AM (#17203446)
But coal and renewables are very different, unless you also buy lots of storage.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by manicdee on Saturday June 02, 2018 @01:39AM (#17212922)
The issue has been done to death in academic circles. All we need to do is stop subsidising coal and nuclear, focus on investing in (companies rolling out) renewables, and let the propeller heads get the job done.

Here's one recent take on the issue: https://reneweconomy.com.au/a-100-renewable-grid-isnt-just-f...

Note that last bit: as we shift to a transport fleet consisting of more and more EVs, the possibility of using storage to balance out demand vs supply becomes more likely, without huge investment in utility scale static batteries.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by Baeocystin on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:54PM (#17210169)
No perhaps about it. Natural gas is far better a fossil fuel to burn than coal per BTU.

Still not ideal, of course. But it absolutely has its place as a transition fuel as we work to decarbonize our energy production.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by manicdee on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:41PM (#17223832)
For the same money we can build solar and wind plant faster than gas, with the benefit of not using fossil fuels and increasing the rate of greenhouse gas emissions.

Methane is not a transition fuel, it is simply a smoke and mirrors truck replacing some of the CO2 emissions of coal with methane emissions from well to furnace. Methane is far worse than carbon dioxide, we should not be following plans to increase methane emissions for a token reduction of CO2 emissions.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:03AM (#17202940)
Actually, this isn't very complicated compared to a modern high-efficiency gas (combined cycle) powerplant or coal (integrated gasification) powerplant, especially when you take into account the exhaust cleaning systems to remove NOx and CO and other nasties that those existing options need.

As I understand it, the new research needed to make this happen is on making new components work (like the high pressure supercritical combustor they mention in TFA). The process complexity isn't anything remarkable.

As for PV: we are nowhere close to having feasible mature solutions for large scale day-to-day (or even intra-day) energy storage. Take the "world record" Tesla system in Australia that gets talked about a lot. In the hypothetical (and IMO entirely unfeasible) scenario where Australia switches to PV to replace coal and gas, and you wanted to use this Tesla solution to store energy from one day to the next to cover just a 20% variability in PV electricity production, you'd need to install more than 10 000 such facilities, at a cost of the order of magnitude of 1 trillion USD. For Australia alone.

So since we don't have that kind of energy storage, we need at the very least 40-50% baseline generation capacity from gas turbines (CO2-emitting or clean), hydroelectric and nuclear power.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by mhandley on Friday June 01, 2018 @06:52AM (#17204191)
If you're trying to cover a 20% variability in PV from day to day, isn't it cheaper to just 20% overprovision PV? You can use the spare electricity on good days for desalination or aluminium smelting, or something that doesn't mind an intermittent cycle.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by martinald on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:49AM (#17204775)
In the UK low winter PV production is something like 5% of summer peak production.

That means you would need to 20x overprovision solar in winter, plus you have a massive problem that you have 20x overgeneration in summer months (what do you do with all that energy?).

Battery storage doesn't help with this, as you'd need an absolutely enormous amount of storage to net off summer production with winter usage, and the batteries would basically be full for months then ran down in winter, to never be charged again until summer, so probably one cycle a year.

UK has good wind resource and does generate a lot through that, but it also tends to be less on very cold winter days (when power requirement is at its peak).

Overall I think the best option right now for the UK is something like 50% PV/wind, 25% nuclear baseload and the rest natural gas peaking plants. Even this would be very expensive, the peaking plants will be turned on and off a lot (high maintenance costs) and sitting idle probably throughout the entire summer.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by adrianN on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:57AM (#17204821)
You could always use surplus energy to extract carbon from the atmosphere and turn it to liquid fuel.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by rhino369 on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:12AM (#17204538)
PV output at different stations are pretty highly correlated.

I also think that variability is a lot more than just 20%. I think there is 50% variation between December and July in most of the USA just based on sunlight.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by pjc50 on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:26AM (#17204633)
Yes, seasonality is big and gets bigger the further north you go. I'm at 56N and recorded data to make a graph: https://flatline.org.uk/daystats.html
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by pjc50 on Friday June 01, 2018 @01:35AM (#17202832)
So long as oil is in demand, there is methane as a byproduct. Both from conventional drilling and fracking. If it's not used it will be "flared": burnt directly to the atmosphere with no useful byproduct.

E.g. http://www.naturalgasintel.com/articles/114565-bakken-natura...

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by mirimir on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:00AM (#17202928)
Huh? Methane is a versatile feedstock. Haber process for ammonia. Also methanol and acetic acid, and from them, just about anything.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by pjc50 on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:51AM (#17203128)
Yes, but we don't need that much of it for chemical purposes and it's burnt in huge quantities because it's a pain to ship and low value.

Nigeria flares something like 700 million cubic feet of gas every day due to lack of transport infrastructure.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by microcolonel on Friday June 01, 2018 @03:57AM (#17203432)
Seems like a quick and dirty (and cheap!) thermal engine would be a big upgrade, compared to just burning it. Not the sort of thing your average "environmentalist" would be into, though.
Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by thinkcontext on Friday June 01, 2018 @09:42AM (#17205192)
If it were economic to do that don't you think it would be done? Oil companies have been at this for a while and are not known for throwing away money. The basic problem is wells are remote and flaring is intermittent.

Why would environmentalists have a problem with flaring versus using the heat from combustion to do something? Environmentalists would be in favor of putting a price on the CO2 emitted from burning or perhaps limiting oil production that leads to flaring.

Re:In Texas, a new power plant could redefine carbon capture by gwbas1c on Friday June 01, 2018 @10:08AM (#17205435)
The short answer is that we don't know how to economically stockpile energy created by solar panels for the winter.

I just set my house up to be very close to "net zero" with electric heating and one plug-in vehicle, but the system works by overproducing in the summer and underproducing in the winter.

The cost would be double or triple if the system had batteries and was capable of generating enough energy to heat my home in the winter.