News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by seldo on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:00PM (#1720080)
A dime per user is nice and all, but they need to make 20x that for a billion dollars in revenue. That's still only $2 per user, but a lot harder.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by nadam on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:08PM (#1720124)
My gut feeling is that Facebook is somewhat overvalued at $33billion. (This is $66 for their average user.) But I don't think it is overvalued by orders of magnitudes and I think the 37signals article is very demagogue.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by mrtron on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:23PM (#1720190)
People are horrible at taking variables like growth into account.

It isn't 66$ per user. It is 33billion/expected number of total users over the lifetime of facebook.

So if you throw in rough estimates of 2 billion facebook users and give them a decade of profiting from an average user...3$ per year per user.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by InclinedPlane on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:43PM (#1720254)
Which means that if Facebook's valuation rises over the next decade there will be an even bigger gap between their user base * revenue per user than there is today. Either that or their valuation will have to remain flat for the next decade.

Does anybody else see a problem in that?

A company's valuation can certainly take into account growth potential, but when it assumes massive growth and leaves no margin bad things happen. Risk is much higher since any faltering of the company would need to be adjusted for in stock price almost instantly. If a normal company sees slower than expected growth the stock may fall a little. If an overenthusiatically future valued company sees slower than expected growth the stock may tumble by huge margins (because it's tied to the company's size 10 years from now, not today). Worse yet, if there's no margin remaining in stock price it'll be forced to remain stagnant for a very long time. This is bad for investors and bad for the company (because the use of stock as employee compensation is less potent).

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by poet on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:33PM (#1720219)
It strikes me as a bad plan to depend on 400% growth that's sustainable over a decade. You're right, people are horrible at taking growth variables into account. They usually overestimate them.

Facebook may well achieve the numbers outlined above. But let's not kid ourselves. People were doing the same back of the envelope calculations for MySpace when it first started to get big. I see nothing wrong with a judicious use of common sense and caution in this case.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by nadam on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:37PM (#1720235)
Things are changing very fast in this industry. So even 10 years and 2 billion users are optimistic numbers. And if you take 2 billion users, most of these users are from very poor countries, it is extremely hard to monetize these users (almost orders of magnitudes harder than users from rich countries.). That said, I don't think that Facebook is overvalued by orders of magnitudes, and the 37signals article did not make much sense to me.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by mikeryan on Thursday September 23, 2010 @03:51PM (#1721061)
2 billion active users is almost 1/3 of the worlds population. That seems like a strech.

Also you can't link the 33billion to expected. 33billion is their "valuation" now with 500M active users. There's a certain expectation that your valuation should go up as users increase.

Personally I think the per-user deal is kind of a red-herring. Revenues and Profits are the only things that really matter. Users are just a one (good) dataset for estimating growth - but hardly the only one.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by TWAndrews on Thursday September 23, 2010 @05:03PM (#1721440)
"rough estimates of 2 billion facebook users"

Right. Because the Chinese and Indian Peasantry is definitely going to be on FB.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by skyepn on Thursday September 23, 2010 @07:43PM (#1722022)
Not to mention other platforms are more popular in other countries. For example, Google's Orkut is very popular in Brazil and I'm sure Baidu et al are working on offerings for the Chinese market. USA != world
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by spolsky on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:02PM (#1720090)
They're almost certainly making $2 per user. Another dime is gonna be easy.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by bhickey on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:14PM (#1720156)
First of all, Joel, it's THEY'RE not THERE. ;)
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by shadowmatter on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:51PM (#1720280)
Hey, lay off man! If Chicago doesn't have to teach multiplication, New York doesn't have to teach grammar, alright?
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by blusie on Thursday September 23, 2010 @01:00PM (#1720317)
Read the original post, Joel didn't make that mistake.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by lrm242 on Thursday September 23, 2010 @03:43PM (#1721019)
lol, he edited it.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by lovskogen on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:30PM (#1720209)
Haven't got a dime from me, and they don't have an idea on how to.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by moe on Thursday September 23, 2010 @01:01PM (#1720319)
Also a dime per user/year is more than it seems when you can only collect it through indirect means (ads, charging other companies for using your platform). Remember their ~500mio user figure also includes the overwhelming portion of users who generate no more than a handful of page impressions per month.

It's not like facebook could invent a yearly membership fee or start selling t-shirts or such...

Well, they could, but I doubt more than ~20% of their audience would actually pay.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by marclove on Thursday September 23, 2010 @03:35PM (#1720993)
They'd be lucky if ~0.5% of their audience would actually pay.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by timcederman on Thursday September 23, 2010 @01:28PM (#1720444)
You don't think so, but they probably have.

I always used to think I was a 'leech' user of TripAdvisor, until I worked there.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by portman on Thursday September 23, 2010 @05:33PM (#1721567)
Have you viewed more than 300 pages on the facebook.com domain in your lifetime?

If so, they've gotten a dime from you.

3 ads per page, each ad selling at a $0.10 CPM.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by krschultz on Thursday September 23, 2010 @12:48PM (#1720267)
I think their CPM is in the $30-$40 range, but the key missing piece of information is how many views they get per user. I know my Facebook use has gone from multiple views per day (20, 40?) to 1 page every other day. Still lets say each user looks at Facebook twicer per day, each user is about 1/2 a CPM per year, or $20 revenue per year.

But CPC, well I've never clicked on an ad on Facebook in my entire life.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by mikeklaas on Thursday September 23, 2010 @02:29PM (#1720709)
Never use tech-savvy people as representative examples when evaluating advertising.

Otherwise, even google would be out of business.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by krschultz on Thursday September 23, 2010 @04:41PM (#1721351)
The problem with the comparison of Facebook VS Google is that Google advertising is fantastically targeted.

You literally type into Google "I have this problem" and get a bunch of ads solving that problem. It is practically the holy grail of advertising. Now consider that it is a catch all for personal and corporate questions, it is a cash cow. It is perfectly acceptable to google something at your job, click on a link, and buy a $15,000 system.

Facebook might know a lot about you, but they don't know what you are looking for at any given moment. Add on top that most people are spending their time on personal relationships, and it isn't the same even if they get more impressions. I can't log into Facebook from work and say "who has 5" diameter pipe?" and expect a response, but if I google that I find a vendor and place a multi thousand dollar order.

Also the market on Facebook is somewhat inverted. The "best" customers are generally on their the least. The most frequent people are college students - mostly broke at that. If you aren't advertising clothes, personal electronics, or local bars I don't see the draw.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by portman on Thursday September 23, 2010 @05:29PM (#1721544)
Speaking as someone who has spent $30,000 on Facebook ads in the last several months: Facebook advertising is fantastically targeted as well.

Google ads work when there is so-called "purchase intent": I know I want a new waffle maker, so I search for it.

Facebook ads work when there is demographic correlation: I just got engaged, and I might not know that I now need a waffle maker, but a Facebook ad can target me and tell me that I should be adding a waffle maker to my wedding registry.

Different kids of targeting, both extremely powerful.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by toolate on Thursday September 23, 2010 @10:02PM (#1722317)
So you're the one putting all those wedding ads on my Facebook page. I hate you.
Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by portman on Thursday September 23, 2010 @10:45PM (#1722435)
Congratulations on your engagement!

And seriously. Waffle maker. It's the gift that keeps on giving.

Re:Facebook is not worth $33 billion by dotcoma on Thursday September 23, 2010 @04:50PM (#1721387)
you must be kidding, right? If their CPM were $30-40 they'd be making many billions per year, not (maybe) 1 billion.