News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Build2, a Cargo-like dependency and build manager for C/C++ by umanwizard on Thursday May 31, 2018 @12:04AM (#17193852)
> Any sufficiently large software project can't rely on the distribution to provide anything for them.

This is factually wrong. I'm able to compile things as complicated as clang/llvm, firefox, and LibreOffice relying mostly on dependencies installed through the distribution's package manager.

Re:Build2, a Cargo-like dependency and build manager for C/C++ by orbifold on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:03AM (#17196816)
It is not, just take a look at the third party directory of chromium, where it tracks all its third party dependencies

https://github.com/chromium/chromium/tree/master/third_party

the main point of their build system gn (similar to bazel) is to have explicit and distribution independent control of all dependencies (typically tied to specific versions).

LLVM basically has no system dependencies as well, instead it implements a lot of platform abstractions within the repository (https://github.com/llvm-mirror/llvm/tree/master/lib/Support), the remaining dependencies are mostly build dependencies such as python 2.7 and cmake.

Same story for Cryengine (https://github.com/CRYTEK/CRYENGINE/tree/release/Code/Libs) and Unreal Engine (https://github.com/EpicGames/UnrealEngine/tree/release/Engin...).

Linux distributions simply duplicate a lot of work because they are based on a flawed and outdated distribution model, outdated because the main argument for shared libraries disappears with > 1 TB commodity hard drives. The approach taken by the projects above is also the only way to do cross platform development, simply because both Windows, macOS and Consoles don't have the concept of an operating system package manager. (If you are using homebrew for development on mac, you will run into a lot of trouble sooner or later).

Re:Build2, a Cargo-like dependency and build manager for C/C++ by takluyver on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:20AM (#17194565)
Clang, Firefox and LibreOffice are all likely to be in distro packages themselves, so their build dependencies have to be there as well. Building something of similar complexity that isn't already packaged would be a fairer test.
Re:Build2, a Cargo-like dependency and build manager for C/C++ by exDM69 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @02:45AM (#17194420)
The distro package manager is there to provide your day to day apps and the libraries to support it.

Sooner or later you will run into an issue where your development work will depend on a (version) of a library that will break an app you depend on.

Or you will need two versions of a library for your previous and next release which both need maintenance.

Nor do they provide reproducible builds and other features that are needed for serious work.

Distro package managers are not suited for development and dependency management. They might work most of the time, but that is not good enough.

Re:Build2, a Cargo-like dependency and build manager for C/C++ by erik_seaberg on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:37AM (#17194634)
The distro package manager is there to offer a menu of compatible known-good dependencies that you can readily adopt. It's a ton of work you don't need to do. If instead you bundle random stuff committed last month, you should have a compelling reason for beginning to maintain a half-baked distro all by yourself.