It's a fair response to Krugman - Krugman mostly doesn't discuss mechanisms, details, or include caveats. He just pushes the assertion more spending is good, if stimulus failed it's because it wasn't big enough, etc. Occasionally he makes false accusations against his ideological opponents (e.g., the Paul Ryan fiasco).
If a columnist is responding Paul Krugman or Glenn Beck types, you shouldn't expect much in the way of depth.
By equating these two in the same sentence, you undermined all credibility in your previous message. Sorta sad to see an implosion like that.
But I suppose I am being a bit unfair in one respect. Unlike Krugman, Beck is occasionally willing to admit that some of the other teams ideas are not that bad (e.g., gay marriage).
While these two (together, or shall I say in opposition with Keynes) helped lay an important parts of foundation of modern economics, their ideas are just about as relevant nowadays as Newton mechanics to building an interstellar spaceship.
Perhaps next time this, err, nobody ("James Quinn is a senior director of strategic planning for a major university") feels like trashing world class economists, he could discuss their actual opinion?