Re:Three-sided Football
by blocked_again on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @02:14AM
(#17185478)
Winner of a game in a normal football is also the one who cedes the fewest goal of the two.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Three-sided Football
by glaberficken on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @04:17AM
(#17185995)
But crucially here is that on a 3 sided game that rule is not symmetrical anymore.
On 1v1 saying that the winner is the one who concedes the least or that scores the most is equivalent.
Whereas on a 3 sided game it is not equivalent. See this example below (if you change the rule a different team will have won the game):
Team X: Scored/Conceded
Team A: 4/5
Team B: 5/3 (winner if highest scorer wins)
Team C: 1/2 (winner if lowest "conceder" wins)
[Edited to make the total scored and conceded add up to the same number.]
Re:Three-sided Football
by irishsultan on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @06:21AM
(#17186488)
An alternative measure would be "best goal difference", which also would make team B the winner in your example, but wouldn't necessarily be the same as highest scorer, or lowest conceder.
As seen in an alternative outcome, this gives us 3 potential winners.
Team X: Scored/Conceded
Team A: 6/4 (winner if best goal difference wins)
Team B: 7/6 (winner if highest scorer wins)
Team C: 0/3 (winner if lowest "conceder" wins)
Re:Three-sided Football
by TimTheTinker on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @01:23PM
(#17189600)
This would fail to penalize a team that accidentally knocks the ball into their own goal, unless you add a special case rule for that scenario.
And if you didn't special case it would lead to an "interesting" strategy of trying to score on yourself whenever you were in serious danger of having someone else score on you.
It would often be quite impossible to determine which team scored a goal, for instance in 'scrimmage' situations, or own goals.
Plus it would create weird situations where a attacking team would stop a goal from the other attacking team on the line and try to get in on their own name.
Re:Three-sided Football
by oneeyedpigeon on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @08:58AM
(#17187293)
That's a problem in 2-team football, anyway (the individual who scored always has to be identified), although the point you raise about own goals is an interesting one. Maybe an own-goal should award half a goal to the other two teams?
The player who scored is identified, but it doesn't really matter because it goes to the scoring team regardless of who scored it.
How do you have 11 scored goals and only 7 conceded goals?
Re:Three-sided Football
by JoeSmithson on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @04:38AM
(#17186070)
They got A the wrong way around
Re:Three-sided Football
by glaberficken on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @04:44AM
(#17186101)
Yeah, sorry edited fixed!