Your reasoning does seem sound. I'm sure there is plenty of data to that effect - and I'm equally sure that nobody outside Facebook has access to it.
I think I might pony up $10 or $20 a month to know I was in control and to suppress all ads. I'm nearly certain I'm unusual in that regard, though.
It wouldn't surprise me if it would cost me 10-15 USD per month to cover the ad revenue FB is getting for me and my data, and the question is if I really would be willing to pay that.
[1]: https://medium.com/@mlvb_at/facebook-earnings-q1-2018-a-real... [2]: I'm not sure if this reasoning is sound, but it seems resonable. I wonder if there is data/estimations on the distribution of ad revenue per user.