Re:Will Kubernetes Collapse Under the Weight of Its Complexity?
by pas on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @04:58AM
(#17177508)
K8s is a great system manager. A natural evolution of config management and containerization.
And it's good for deploying big systems with lots of moving parts (such a OpenStack, or any proprietary system, let's say a big e-commerce site).
And even if the problem is straightforward (just run these docker containers, just do this rolling upgrade, just do setup these nginx load balancers, just add these to monitoring), all of these are a chore, especially if done right. And config managers always fail at the premise of apply changes to a "known state" (or they spend an eternity checking the state), so why not fuse actual monitoring with config management, and a lot of nice concepts fall out automatically, like Deployments. No longer do you have to disable the alerting part of monitoring, or mark certain parts of the telemetry time series as irrelevant for SLA accounting because we were deploying (or cobble together scripts to handle this for you), and then evolve the whole system as the underlying components (the things that are being deployed) change.
Sure, k8s is not there yet, as the problem is big, complex, and hard to get right even in parts, but a lot better already than the simple one-man-army homegrown solutions. (IMHO)
And it's good for deploying big systems with lots of moving parts (such a OpenStack, or any proprietary system, let's say a big e-commerce site).
And even if the problem is straightforward (just run these docker containers, just do this rolling upgrade, just do setup these nginx load balancers, just add these to monitoring), all of these are a chore, especially if done right. And config managers always fail at the premise of apply changes to a "known state" (or they spend an eternity checking the state), so why not fuse actual monitoring with config management, and a lot of nice concepts fall out automatically, like Deployments. No longer do you have to disable the alerting part of monitoring, or mark certain parts of the telemetry time series as irrelevant for SLA accounting because we were deploying (or cobble together scripts to handle this for you), and then evolve the whole system as the underlying components (the things that are being deployed) change.
Sure, k8s is not there yet, as the problem is big, complex, and hard to get right even in parts, but a lot better already than the simple one-man-army homegrown solutions. (IMHO)