Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mist...
by mkramlich on Thursday September 23, 2010 @01:17AM
(#1718666)
> I used to be a mechanical engineer for several space shuttle missions.
I voted you up for this sentence alone. It makes anything else that follows that you say inherently more valuable to the discussion. thanks for contributing.
Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mist...
by damoncali on Thursday September 23, 2010 @04:40PM
(#1721346)
I would hope my comments stood on their own, but sometimes it's necessary to shed some light on the bias inherent in one's comments... I can't pretend to be an objective observer on this one.
Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mist...
by mturmon on Thursday September 23, 2010 @03:50AM
(#1718898)
It's not about the ability to find astronauts to accept the risk.
It's about the blow to national prestige and to NASA when such a disaster happens. The public will not abide a spacecraft with the flag on it, crashing.
Re:The Wrong Stuff: NASA Astronaut on Making and Fixing Mist...
by damoncali on Thursday September 23, 2010 @04:39PM
(#1721339)
That is absolutely true. The public cannot handle the truth, to paraphrase a fictitious Marine. But the proper way to go about this is not to pretend that it is safe, which causes people to wonder what's wrong with NASA, but rather to embrace the risk, so that people understand what is going on.
That a shuttle (and it's crew) blows up is regrettable, but when you strap a cargo truck to a giant tank of hydrogen and light it on fire, someone is going to die from time to time. It's not like they don't know what they're getting into.
Figuring out how to keep the crew alive after the shuttle's main tank explodes is just a bad idea. Wouldn't it make more sense to figure out a way to keep the rockets from coming apart in the first place? How many additional failure points would you introduce by creating a failsafe for that unlikely case (of which there are thousands if not millions).
Of course we should learn from failures, but the surest way to kill the space program is force it to be safer. If anything, they need to inject more risk into space flight so that better technologies can gain the ever-elusive "flight heritage". Trust me, astronauts would still line up for a chance to fly even if you doubled the risk of death.