All GPU-mined coins (except the hashrate-dominant one: Ethereum) are massively vulnerable to majority attacks because of the huge pre-existing installed based of GPU miners.
As I said in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17173774 the only solid defense is for each coin to implement an ASIC-friendly algorithm that is unique to this coin, so there is no risk of 51% attacks from a pre-existing installed based of miners.
* genuine decentralization
* reliably generates a concensus with global supermajority, little or no forking (objective chain selection)
* fault tolerant network, minimal fragility / auto recovering, can't be permanently crashed / hijacked
* requires no human intervention
Everything I've seen so far in terms of PoS violates at least one of the above.
Hashgraph doesn't deal with concensus (it offload that to other layers), Ripple doesn't really deal with decentralization, Algorand is fragile, most PoS require human intervention besides often having several other faults.
Also there's probably more criteria like these that matter.
"Genuine decentralization" / and "consensus" are not necessary to make a useful currency.
There's also massive cost and risk with the currencies that do implement those criteria.
We should all be open to different alternatives that WORK, and not reject them out of hand just because they're not implemented in such a way that they have attributes we LIKE.
This is a really good point, and part of what I am hoping people come to understand from this website. Ignoring the risk of renting power from NiceHash to launch an attack, large existing miners could easily switch to a smaller coin for a few hours to attack it, and typically it would be very profitable.
that was literally stated
Paraphrased: there's no risk, except that you lose all of your money (because your coins are now worthless).
This is a little different from how people have been told to think about it before which is just focusing on the blockchain itself rather than the mining power behind any given variation/fork/whatever of block chain.
Ps. And that probably should be taken a step further. If you have families of coins that are all GPU mined, then you need to consider the tota GPUs mining them and the hashing power of those GPUs and the ability for them to switch functions. Now GPUs are a blip on ASICs so for the predominantly asic mined coins this doesn’t matter.