Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by sfk on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @03:53PM
(#171803)
The title of the list is a gross misnomer. Half of the people on the list are political activists of some sort.
Take Barenboim. Why is he an intellectual? He is a fantastic pianist, a (IMHO) mediocre conductor and an activist for peace in the middle east.
Take Ayaan Hirsi Ali. She is a Dutch politician who build her entire career upon the fact that she has suffered a lot being raised as a female Muslim. She is definitely not what I would call an intellectual.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by kkshin on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @04:18PM
(#171830)
For better or for worse, the modern connotation of an intellectual is heavily slanted towards the matters of humanities and arts. I've had the pleasure of studying under some great computer scientists, but unfortunately, although geniuses in their field, very few of them could be considered an "intellectual" in the current form of its meaning.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by neilc on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @04:25PM
(#171838)
Note that the list is of public intellectuals -- intellectuals who play a prominent role in public discourse. Most great computer scientists tend to stay out of the public realm, for the most part -- and perhaps with good reason.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by menloparkbum on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @05:22PM
(#171903)
"He has an anti-ear, and it's absolutely infallible; he is a Joyce or a Flaubert in reverse, incapable of rendering even the smallest details without genius."
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by mattrepl on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @03:38PM
(#171790)
There are two biologists, one physicist, one neuroscientist, and one medical scientist. The list is dominated by individuals with careers in politics, religion, literature, philosophy, and history.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by krschultz on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @04:22PM
(#171835)
I agree, a list of the Top 100 Intellectuals would be dominated by mathematicians, scientists, engineers, and probably a hacker or to, but this list is titled The Top 100 PUBLIC Intellectuals, i.e. public policy, so I wasn't expecting any different.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by mechanical_fish on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @04:04PM
(#171816)
I'm not nominating anyone. I don't think being named to the list of "100 random names, compiled over a round of beers at a Foreign Policy office party, that make you sound sophisticated when you drop them" is a very high honor.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by geebee on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @04:39PM
(#171860)
That's an interesting question. I think that the software world (distinct from CS or Math) does have "public intellectuals", though they are rarely known outside software. I'd say that Eric Raymond, David Heinemeier Hansson, Paul Graham, Joel Spolsky, Kathy Sierra, and Linus Torvalds are "public intellectuals" within this space. Many of these folks have impressive tech accomplishments, but people know who they are largely because they've read their writings/essays about software (ie., I'm distinguishing people who are known purely on the basis of code). It's very difficult to become a software public intellectual without reasonably impressive technical achievements, though I'd probably say Lawrence Lessig is in the club.
Re:Only one computer scientist in the world's top 100 public...
by mdemare on Wednesday April 23, 2008 @07:36PM
(#172017)
I find it very hard to believe that Slavoj Zizek is better known, or more influential, than, say, Linus, RMS, PG, Joel, ESR or many others in our field.
Take Barenboim. Why is he an intellectual? He is a fantastic pianist, a (IMHO) mediocre conductor and an activist for peace in the middle east.
Take Ayaan Hirsi Ali. She is a Dutch politician who build her entire career upon the fact that she has suffered a lot being raised as a female Muslim. She is definitely not what I would call an intellectual.
http://www.nypress.com/18/16/news&columns/taibbi.cfm
>Yegor Gaidar, Russia, Economist, politician
>Gaidar was Boris Yeltsin’s acting prime minister from June 15 to December 14, 1992 and a proponent of “shock therapy” for the Russian economy.
>He is a contributing editor to FP.
That should make clear both the quality and the nature of this publication.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Accomplishment
In my opinion Godel was the greatest mathematician of the 20th century, but he's dead.
Silly, vague, badly defined list.