News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:54AM (#17166251)
Absolutely, but not getting linked to has always been an option.

Publishers want Google to link to their content. At the same time they want Google to pay for the honor and prevent competitors from letting Google link to their content for free.

The only reason this ridiculously brazen set of demands doesn't get laughed out of the room is that these publishers have tremendous political clout.

Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by kuschku on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:31AM (#17166481)
The big issue is that Google over time has moved to scrape the web.

One big thing Google has done recently is they extract what you search for from a website, and show it inline.

E.g. when I search for a recipe, I get the result in the Google search, and don’t need to visit their website. https://i.k8r.eu/aILGEg

Google extracts reviews from Yelp!, and I can read them without visiting Yelp!.

They’re doing this for everything, and AMP furthers this.

Google is trying to keep the user as long as possible on Google, and show snippets instead of letting users leave.

As result many of these sites lose out on ad impressions, and money.

Google has no way to disable this feature short of entire unlisting your site.

Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:42AM (#17166506)
I can see the problem with that. But as I understand it the proposed "link tax" is not limited to this sort of thing.
Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by kuschku on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:51AM (#17166527)
Yeah, it’s why I hate the law as it is, but I can obviously also understand why Google seems like a threat to the actors behind this.
Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by cabalamat on Sunday May 27, 2018 @10:05AM (#17166916)
> The big issue is that Google over time has moved to scrape the web.

This is true, and a lot of Google's practices are monopolistic/hegemonic.

However banning/taxing links is not the answer.

Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by kuschku on Sunday May 27, 2018 @10:31AM (#17166993)
But what are you gonna do about it then? Ban snippets? Tax snippets? Wait for Google to be the web? Specially regulate Google?

There’s no good solutions.

Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by cabalamat on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:18PM (#17168246)
> But what are you gonna do about it then? Ban snippets? Tax snippets? Wait for Google to be the web? Specially regulate Google?

I think I would ban search engines from doing other things, ban or regulate targetted advertising, require social networks to be interoperable, and ban social networks from owning other social networks (so Facebook would have to sell off Instagram).

Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by kuschku on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:20PM (#17168259)
That’s an idea I can agree with, and that Vestager visibly sympathizes with, but that’d mean breaking apart Google, and as result would anger a lot of people.
Re:EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the ... by speedplane on Saturday June 02, 2018 @04:24AM (#17213482)
Google's stated goal is to provide people access to information. But in reality, they provide access to what's easily accessible to them. Any robots.txt tool is far too blunt of an instrument. It does not respect other highly valued goals of privacy, competitive fairness, and comprehensiveness, among others.

To put it more starkly, to assist with privacy, there should be a robots.txt tag/line that allows scraping, but prohibits indexing anything that is tagged as "personally identifiable information". It should be easy to Google what the newest bankruptcy law is, but should be a bit harder to figure out if a specific person filed for bankruptcy.

Similarly, with comprehensiveness, robots.txt should be able to say "don't index these pages unless you also index those pages". For example, a medical site should be able to say, you can index these several name-brand drugs but only if you also index their generic equivalents.

And as far as fairness, a better robots.txt should be able to tell Google to index the portions of its content to attract clicks, but prevent them from scraping their most valuable content. For example, Yelp may allow them to index a restaraunt's overall rating, but not summarize their reviews.