Re:USB Reverse Engineering: Down the Rabbit Hole
by mng2 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @12:58AM
(#17165495)
To be fair, specs and standards generally aren't written as introductions, so they're kind of hard to make sense of when starting from zero. USB, with its infernal descriptors and endpoints, benefits mightily from third-party explanations.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:USB Reverse Engineering: Down the Rabbit Hole
by alias1 on Monday May 28, 2018 @12:06AM
(#17170528)
Definitely agree here. I tend to like to get the gist of things/cliffnotes from people that have already broken it down, and then deep dive into the spec if I need to know some explicit detail.
Most of the time when I want to hack on something, a super high level abstraction is more than sufficient for my needs (eg. don't need to understand the inner workings of a CPU if all I need is an API). But then there are those times when the spec, in all it's verbose rawness, is the perfect tool for the job.
Re:USB Reverse Engineering: Down the Rabbit Hole
by forapurpose on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:35AM
(#17165588)
> specs and standards generally aren't written as introductions
Sometimes, but I often find them to be pretty good, and if I look at third party sources first, I usually wish I'd come to the spec much sooner in the process; the actual spec tends to make most third party sources redundant or plainly erroneous.
But of course, not all specs are equal; some are unreadable or poor introductions.