Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by psergeant on Saturday May 26, 2018 @10:53AM
(#17162347)
There’s some weird Russian connection here isn’t there?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by nneonneo on Saturday May 26, 2018 @11:02AM
(#17162399)
I don't disagree - George Galloway and several of the subjects mentioned have connections to RT, Sputnik, etc. Philip Cross has had to remove a fairly sizable amount of content that was only sourced to RT and Sputnik (which are not considered reliable, neutral sources). There's a nonzero probability of a Russian connection.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by coliveira on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:25PM
(#17162850)
In matters of war, RT is as reliable as NYTimes. Both are reliably biased, RT to Russia and NYT to American interests. For me at least it is useful to see what each country's narrative is.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by psergeant on Saturday May 26, 2018 @02:20PM
(#17163504)
Have you ever seen an RT article deeply critical of Putin’s regime?
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by abalone on Saturday May 26, 2018 @02:59PM
(#17163687)
American media has vigorous criticism within a certain range (roughly the Democrat-Republican spectrum), but it is supportive of common elite interests. For example you will find the NYT rarely criticized on moral grounds the wars that the US waged. Speaking of Herman and Chomsky, Manufacturing Consent is a good analysis of this phenomenon (propaganda in democratic societies), with supporting evidence.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by k1m on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:40PM
(#17162915)
Feel the same.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by andybak on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:04PM
(#17162736)
Quite possibly from my reading of the situation. Doesn't necessarily invalidate the claims against Cross however.
Sadly the aims of groups with good intent and those with bad intent sometimes coincide.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by StanislavPetrov on Saturday May 26, 2018 @11:43AM
(#17162620)
Only insofar as the hysteria about Russia has been interjected into every issue by people caught up in the frenzy. The truth is that the propaganda arms of a variety of countries have been deeply involved in shaping, controlling and attempting to influence media and social dialogue for many, many years (with by far the most "successful" being the CIA/USA with Israel as a close second and Russia lagging far behind).
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by k1m on Saturday May 26, 2018 @11:36AM
(#17162578)
Very convenient to dismiss evidence with baseless accusations.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by hellbanner on Saturday May 26, 2018 @10:58AM
(#17162375)
ctrl-f on site for "Russian": 0 results.
Same for russia, kremlin.
Don't spread FUD.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by Shank on Saturday May 26, 2018 @11:05AM
(#17162421)
Okay, so I don't consider @psergeant's comment to be the most open, but he is suggesting it only because WP:ANB is (specifically, Guy's initial proposal).
> George Galloway is not "anti-war", he's an activist for Palestine and supports Russia's involvement in Syria - he may be anti some wars but the claim of "anti-war" is at best questionable. (from Guy)
> Also on May 14, the conflict spilled over into wider media. RT published "Mystery figure targets anti-war pundits and politicians by prolifically editing Wikipedia" and two days later Sputnik followed with an interview of George Galloway, "Who's Philip Cross: 'Either a Mad Obsessionist or State Operative' – Galloway". (from KalHolmann)
So, while this comment does seem a but unjustified, it is validated by the initial requests to refer to ArbCom.
Re:Update: The agenda-driven edits of Philip Cross and Wikip...
by user982 on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:00PM
(#17162716)
That he considers activism for Palestine "pro-war" is telling in and of itself.