News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:27PM (#17158598)
This is the upper middle class robbing poor people. The projected fare would be $86 per ticket, about triple the cost of driving for a family of four. The people who are going to pay that are upper middle class travelers and business travelers. Which would be fine if the project was paying for itself, but it won’t be. It’ll be state subsidies for high income professionals. That money could be doing so much good (schools, public transit for lower income people, etc.).

For example, the $100+ billion this will eventually cost could create a fund that would perpetually pay (with inflation increases) about $1,200 to every low-income K-12 student in the State.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ebikelaw on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:40PM (#17158714)
No, the upper-middle-class robbing the poor has been the history of our highway system, which you can't use without owning a car and paying ~ $0.55/mile to operate it. We have shoveled hundreds of billions of dollars of subsidies down the throat of the automobile culture and we did not get a functioning transportation system from doing so. We got a massively regressive, barely functional system and all of its attendant externalities in the form of health problems for those living near the roads, and end-of-civilization CO2 pollution problems for people living everywhere.

The cost of HSR suddenly sounds so much more reasonable if you frame it in terms of the road budget. HSR's all-in cost for right-of-way, tracks, stations, and trains is about four years worth of California's current road budget.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:44PM (#17158745)
That's completely divorced from reality. Even poor people own cars! 80% of people in poverty have access to a vehicle.[1] $0.55/mile is about $120 for an LA to SF trip. For a family of four, this train is $350. Which one do you think a low-income family is going to take to visit relatives for Christmas?

In any case, poor people who don't own cars rely on busses and subways--which this boondoggle does nothing for.

[1] $77 billion would also create a perpetual fund that would be able to buy a $10,000 used car for every household in poverty every 5 years.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ebikelaw on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:53PM (#17158814)
That's cherry-picking a favorable example for the car. It's always better to take your car when you fill it up with people, compared to other modes that charge per person. It's true locally - always cheaper to drive from Oakland to San Francisco vs. four round-trip BART tickets - and it's true regionally - cheaper to drive the whole family than to fly, if you don't value your time. Of course both of those assume that you can afford the car and that the car you can afford will survive the trip.

Anyway, your last sentence is wrong. Much of the money under the HSR project is going to local transportation projects. So far they have spent or committed seven billion dollars for Caltrain, BART, Muni, Sacramento RT, Capitol Corridor, ACE, LA Metro, Metrolink, San Diego Blue Line, and Coaster, among others.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:03PM (#17158871)
It's a highly relevant example. What are the reasons a lower-income person might travel from LA to SF? Traveling to visit family is probably the primary reason.

You can see this play out with the Acela on the east coast. It's almost all business travelers or nicely dressed professional looking people. People who can't afford $100+ per ticket take the bus ($35).

Likewise, even lower income people traveling alone aren't going to spend $86 for a ticket on HSR (if it's not more like $100+ by the time it's finally open). They'll pay $35 for a Bolt bus.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ebikelaw on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:14PM (#17158934)
Speaking of disconnected from reality, you seem to be claiming that poor people travel, which they don't. In yet another example of American inequality, the bottom income quartile of families are quite stationary; they can neither afford to move about nor do they have "days off" as such because an American is not legally entitled to any.

The supermajority of American families cannot even afford an unexpected $500 expense; they sure as hell aren't going to blow hundreds to drive to LA.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by jessaustin on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:37PM (#17159071)
'rayiner seems to have argued you in a circle here. He is the one claiming the poor aren't going to ride this train; you hardly contradict him when you argue they aren't going to use cheaper transportation either.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ebikelaw on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:41PM (#17159381)
Not at all. He hasn't addressed my point which is that for individuals travelling alone the train will be dramatically cheaper than driving over long distances.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by tptacek on Saturday May 26, 2018 @01:12AM (#17160348)
You haven't come close to establishing that either. Bus fare from SF to LA is less than half that train ticket price.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by yongjik on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:08PM (#17158893)
Even poor people are forced to own cars because the whole cityscape is designed with that assumption, so they have to shell out thousands of dollars they could've used on food or other niceties, to buy a barely functioning vehicle that costs them more money and time to repair constantly.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by candiodari on Saturday May 26, 2018 @04:27AM (#17160873)
And the alternative would be ?

(Note: those poor people need to be able to do 30-40kg groceries, at a distance of, say 5-10 kilometers, when they're 50 years old)

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by slg on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:54PM (#17158816)
That $0.55 / mile is dropping with EVs (which also help address some of the other problems you mentioned) and would crater if driverless cars become a reality in the next decade or so. A driverless EV should easily be able to beat $86 for a 400 mile trip from SF to LA. Which makes we wonder if the time for high speed rail has come and gone.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ebikelaw on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:56PM (#17158828)
The difference between HSR and driverless EVs that can go from SF to LA is the former has existed for 50 years and the latter has literally never been demonstrated.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by slg on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:02PM (#17158861)
And another difference is that the development of a rail line requires billions in additional public funds (and also takes years if not decades to build) while the development of driverless cars is being paid for by private businesses. Wasn't your initial argument about saving money?
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ebikelaw on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:11PM (#17158910)
That characterization seems hilariously disconnected from the facts, which are that DARPA kick-started autonomous vehicles more than fifteen years ago with millions in government money, and that the vast majority of development of such vehicles has occurred on public roads, mostly in California. The parts that have been developed off-road have been done at an old Air Force base, and if you want to argue that facility is privately funded that will only make your argument sound even more dumb.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by slg on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:49PM (#17159904)
You are right that I should have included a qualifier in that statement that it is not 100% funded by private business but that percentage is probably pretty close. Yes, DARPA got things moving but like you said their investment was in the millions. Google, Uber, Tesla, GM, etc have invested billions into the tech. Once again if this is a question of the effectiveness of the money spent, DARPA's investment in driverless tech greatly exceeds the potential of billions being spent on high speed rail.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by dragonwriter on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:40PM (#17159089)
> And another difference is that the development of a rail line requires billions in additional public funds (and also takes years if not decades to build)

So does building the same capacity in roads. And, even moreso, so does building that plus the extra capacity required for the increased load required to handle on-demand driverless vehicles.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by mmt on Saturday May 26, 2018 @05:03AM (#17160997)
You're implying that there's a direct equivalence, but that's not really true.

Although the parent comment said "rail line", since TFA is, specifically, about HSR, that's a unique rail line in an existing system, which has something of an all-or-nothing construction problem. Having it half finished won't reduce the train travel time between LA and the SFBA for anyone.

Conversely, road capacity can be added incrementally, and, in many cases, when it is, it has an immediate effect for that section [1], providing relief as soon as the money and/or construction resources are available. In rural California, that's more likely to be months and fractions of a billion, not years and billions. The urban parts are slower and more expensive, but only proprotionally so (i.e. HSR is yet slower and even more expensive there, too).

You haven't presented any evidence for your assumption that on-demand driverless vehicles would require extra capacity, especially down a long-haul corridor. At best, that's some very heavy speculation on the operating cost (dominated by tires, suspension, electricty, I'd expect) versus capital cost of keeping enough spares in each metro.

[1] Yes, I'm aware that, at times, it can have a paradoxically negative effect on congestion, but I'm pretty sure that doesn't happen for capacity increases on what are essentially point-to-point corridors.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by dragonwriter on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:37PM (#17159072)
> That $0.55 / mile is dropping with EVs (which also help address some of the other problems you mentioned) and would crater if driverless cars become a reality in the next decade or so.

Driverless cars increase congestion, which increases cost of human travel, once the taxes needed to pay for road construction and maintenance are factored in.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by slg on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:40PM (#17159879)
Which is an investment that we will inevitably have to make at some point. I think it makes more sense to start preparing for that future than spend money on what is appearing to be a stopgap solution like high speed rail.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by icebraining on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:59PM (#17158852)
you can't use without owning a car

Or taking a bus, no? Seems like you can get a trip for under $15.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by bmarquez on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:37PM (#17158687)
It seems like widening Highway 5 and adding a dedicated carpool lane, along with creating a Greyhound-like public transit route from Northern to Southern California would have been more cost effective.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by dmckeon on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:09PM (#17158900)
Count the overpasses on I-5 when you plan to widen it. I think that when self-driving cars become typical (say, >50% of freeway traffic) that alternating 2 & 3 lanes and exploiting them with platoons of SDCs may become feasible.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by kalleboo on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:46PM (#17158760)
FWIW, that's about what a ticket costs on the Japanese high-speed rail as well (for a shorter distance even). The difference is that in Japan, driving is way more expensive due to the heavily-privatized nearly fully-tolled highway system
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by mitchbob on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:45PM (#17158750)
But according to at least one study (1), the California high-speed rail project would be a cost-effective way to reduce greenhouse gases. If there were a tax on carbon that reflected the damage that greenhouse gases are doing to the environment, we'd be flying a lot less, and HSR would be a no-brainer.

(1) https://www.lewis.ucla.edu/publication/cost-effectiveness-re...

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by mc32 on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:46PM (#17158762)
Nah, I’m arguably middle class and I’m getting tired of this boondoggle with its delays and ever spiraling costs. I take my vote back.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by dragonwriter on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:35PM (#17159052)
> This is the upper middle class robbing poor people. The projected fare would be $86 per ticket, about triple the cost of driving for a family of four. The people who are going to pay that are upper middle class travelers and business travelers.

Which is saving the poor money, since otherwise:

(1) The state will pay entirely out of tax money, largely funded through regressive fuel and consumption taxes, with no private component to expand capacity via freeways instead of HSR,

(2) the state will spend the same kind of public money with a partial private subsidy to expand capacity by adding (and replacing existing freeways with) tollways, which not only will taxpayers who don't take trips pay for, but those who do drive will pay more for.

Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by ohazi on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:31PM (#17158630)
At that price I'll continue to fly Southwest. As currently designed, nobody is going to use this thing.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by stefan_ on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:44PM (#17158747)
Where do the US poor travel to?
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:50PM (#17158792)
They travel to visit family just like U.S. rich people! You can travel from say Spokane to Boise in about 7 hours by car, for about $215 in gas and wear-and-tear. That's affordable for all but the poorest people.
Re:Only 31% of California voters want to keep paying for bul... by romwell on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:13PM (#17158924)
They also travel to see places and experience nature, because you don't have to be rich to go to a National Park, for example. Showing one's children what the world outside of <town> looks like is not an inherently unaffordable activity (although it certainly is more available to people with money, and on a different scale).