News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:56AM (#17154936)
I agree with your second paragraph, but not your first. We all agree that the fact that a legal restriction was democratically approved absolutely does not make it moral (e.g., slavery). A nation doesn't have collective rights to do anything; the individual citizens have rights. And if a minority of citizens wants to welcome and employ immigrants in their home or town, there is a burden on the majority provide the same kind of overwhelming justification we require for other restrictions on rights (free-speech, taking of property, etc.) In particular, your suggestion that nations have rights to control immigration suggests it would be OK if nations had explicitly racist immigration policies; indeed we allow individual citizens to have racist policies for who they let into their home on account of that citizen's individual rights (even though we may strongly disapprove of those individuals).

https://openborders.info/

Re:The New Passport-Poor by ng12 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:18PM (#17155176)
> overwhelming justification we require for other restrictions on rights (free-speech, taking of property, etc.)

I'll bite: national security, economic wellness, and social services. A nation exists for the benefit of it's citizens and there are very credible arguments that borders are important for the well-being of the populace.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:37PM (#17155386)
This is too big a topic to get into a full argument here, but let me make one point: a key idea in American jurisprudence, which I suspect is reflected elsewhere and which in any case is right, is that laws that infringe on rights based on justification X must be narrowly tailored to achieve that end. So just saying "economic wellness" is not enough to issue a blanket restriction unless you are infringing on those rights to the minimum possible degree. There are many, many, many way to place very light and focused restrictions on immigration that would achieve such ends, and people don't even talk about them. (E.g., if you're worried about security, make each immigrant pay a fee or bond that, in expectation, covers the costs imposed by the tiny minority of immigrants who commit crimes.) The fact that these aren't seriously considered makes it very clear that no one respects freedom of movement across national borders in the same way they respect freedom of speech of freedom of movement across city borders.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by stcredzero on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:24PM (#17155929)
So just saying "economic wellness" is not enough to issue a blanket restriction unless you are infringing on those rights to the minimum possible degree.

Why the asymmetry? Why shouldn't we apply the same standard to the rights and freedoms of the residents?

There are many, many, many way to place very light and focused restrictions on immigration that would achieve such ends, and people don't even talk about them. (E.g., if you're worried about security, make each immigrant pay a fee or bond that, in expectation, covers the costs imposed by the tiny minority of immigrants who commit crimes.)

That sounds great to me. The reason why such things aren't discussed in the US, is that proponents of such measures are tarred as "racist."

no one respects freedom of movement across national borders in the same way they respect freedom of speech

Because freedom of speech is essential to free societies. The false "freedom of movement across national borders" could well degrade a society. Why isn't there a freedom to move into your house? No government's resources are infinite. Illegal border-crossing only infringes in a less obvious and more indirect way, as compared to someone moving into your living room.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:07PM (#17159214)
> The reason why such things aren't discussed in the US,

They aren't seriously discussed in almost any non-tiny developed country.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by ng12 on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:01AM (#17160127)
Wouldn't you think there's a reason why?
Re:The New Passport-Poor by mistermann on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:21PM (#17155900)
> There are many, many, many way to place very light and focused restrictions on immigration that would achieve such ends

In theory.

> makes it very clear that no one respects freedom of movement across national borders in the same way they respect freedom of speech of freedom of movement across city borders

I can certainly agree with you on that, I am an extremely strong supporter of free speech, and I not only don't respect free movement across borders, I'm very strongly opposed to it.

It sounds like you are working from a master list of universal human rights that I'm not aware of?

Re:The New Passport-Poor by ng12 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:47PM (#17155480)
> The fact that these aren't seriously considered makes it very clear that no one respects freedom of movement across national borders in the same way they respect freedom of speech of freedom of movement across city borders.

Because these are rights guaranteed to American citizens, not universal rights. The UK doesn't have freedom of speech and whether or not I like it that's totally their prerogative. There are also many cities in the world that are not free to move to (Mecca and Pyongyang come to mind).

I don't think there's any precedent for the rights granted via American jurisprudence to be globally, generally applicable.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:55PM (#17156256)
You’re presupposing that “freedom of movement across national borders” is something that exists, like freedom of speech. It does not—it has never been recognized by any society. Nor does it make any sense. Borders demarcate territory controlled by groups of people. Nobody has a “right” to trespass across those borders.

What you’re positing is that groups of people don’t have the right to control and govern physical pieces of territory. That’s facially wrong.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:43PM (#17159391)
I don't know how the existence of moral rights could be facially anything. It's like...two thousand years of philosophy.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by stcredzero on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:13PM (#17155780)
In particular, your suggestion that nations have rights to control immigration suggests it would be OK if nations had explicitly racist immigration policies; indeed we allow individual citizens to have racist policies for who they let into their home on account of that citizen's individual rights (even though we may strongly disapprove of those individuals).

Sorry, but that doesn't follow. That would be tantamount to saying dating preferences ratify racism because society says it's OK that someone has never slept with an Asian woman. Just as someone might have preferences that contextually caused them to not sleep with people of a particular race, nothing precludes a country having genuinely meritocratic policies which happen to favor certain demographics at certain times. Implicit in this argument is the notion that racism is defined only by outcomes. That is illogical and destructive, because it precludes the existence of meritocratic reasons.

Again, this is just the intellectually dishonest use of "racism" as an emotional bludgeon to push an illogical political agenda.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:47PM (#17156768)
You've misinterpreted me. I'm not saying that having immigration restrictions with disparate racial impact necessarily mean the policies are racist (or otherwise immoral). I'm saying that if we thought nations had rights the way individuals had rights, we wouldn't be so accepting of individuals having racist preferences and so against nations having them.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by stcredzero on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:47PM (#17157815)
Only individual humans have human rights. Sovereign powers have rights which are capabilities, allowing the machinery of international law to function and maintain relative peace among sovereign powers. Where the two meet, there is often nastiness. The most dramatic example of this is war.

Borders are like cell membranes which protect the internal workings of civilized life, commerce, and the rule of law. Applying human morality to sovereign powers makes as much sense as applying human morality to cells or galaxies. A sovereign power should protect the individual human rights of its citizens first. This is what makes sense.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:05PM (#17159210)
I was with you until those last two sentences ;)
Re:The New Passport-Poor by stcredzero on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:30PM (#17159330)
You shouldn't mindlessly sacrifice the buoyancy of your lifeboat because of human rights -- if there are already 19 souls aboard and taking one more will sink it. Those aboard get priority.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by mistermann on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:14PM (#17155794)
> A nation doesn't have collective rights to do anything; the individual citizens have rights. And if a minority of citizens wants to welcome and employ immigrants in their home or town, there is a burden on the majority provide the same kind of overwhelming justification we require for other restrictions on rights (free-speech, taking of property, etc.)

This statement seems rather odd to me, I wonder if I am misunderstanding, or my perception of reality is wrong (and has been for basically me entire adult life).

To loosely paraphrase, it kind of sounds like you're stating that borders are (not just should be, but are) open by default, and any restrictions on that must meet a very strict level of justification.

If this a just yet another theory of "how things should be" well that's fine (and I beg to vigorously differ, as I suspect many others would), but it sounds like you think this is the way it is now.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:49PM (#17156221)
> A nation doesn't have collective rights to do anything; the individual citizens have rights.

That’s facially untrue. For example, the right to self determination. It makes no sense to say that an individual has the right to, e.g. have a democratic government. Groups of people have the collective right to form democratic societies.

Re:The New Passport-Poor by jessriedel on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:51PM (#17156792)
That sentence of mine was intended as normative (and disputed), not empirical. So I am indeed criticizing the right to self-determination as confused.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by always_good on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:36PM (#17156653)
You've used the adjective "facially" multiple times now, but I'm not sure what that clarifies.

Are you saying they are superficially wrong, but actually right once you dig beneath the face/surface?

Re:The New Passport-Poor by rayiner on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:20PM (#17157007)
Facially wrong means that it’s an assertion that’s wrong in its face. You don’t have to dig into it to realize it’s wrong.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by detcader on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:04PM (#17155678)
I don't even understand the need for this political science language gymnastics of 'rights'. Everyone considers Harriet Tubman heroic in the context of her nation, because of her anti-oppressive defiance of power. Even though all the things she did was very illegal. Leaders of countries can be heroic in the context of the human race as a whole, by acting against the incentives and wishes of Capital and Whiteness, allowing immigration and helping people. Building public transportation for example.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by stcredzero on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:25PM (#17155947)
Harriet Tubman wasn't fighting against borders. She was standing up to slavery. Slave masters had to compromise borders and sovereignty in the interest of retrieving slaves.
Re:The New Passport-Poor by detcader on Thursday May 31, 2018 @06:35PM (#17200927)
Did I say borders are equivalent to slavery? Why stop there with this interpretation? Maybe I was saying all world leaders should rename themselves Harriet Tubman?

Borders cause suffering when people are trapped in war, violence, poverty. World leaders can ease crossing of borders to give immigrants better opportunities to live. The only reason they don't is because they need to be reelected and have careers after office, at best, and maybe they aspire to favor of the rich and white.