News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by Retric on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:03AM (#17154365)
> reasoning about what science is and does is part of philosophy

Only if you approach Philosophy with a lot more rigor and math than what people have historically done. The useful parts of discussing what you call the 'philosophy of science' involves quite a bit of statistics for example.

What people call useless is cruft dealing with Known Unknowable's which suck up time without getting anywhere.

IMO, it's not that Philosophy is dead, it's just when you keep calling the useful bit's something else eventually people don't care about the leftovers.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by TelmoMenezes on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:18AM (#17154503)
> Only if you approach Philosophy with a lot more rigor and math than what people have historically done. The useful parts of discussing what you call the 'philosophy of science' involves quite a bit of statistics for example.

I disagree. For example, Karl Popper's positions on the philosophy of science became the current mainstream view. His positions are not based on statistics, but on good-old-fashioned qualitative reasoning. I know many scientists who mention Popper by name when discussing such matters. Carl Sagan also helped popularize it in his book "Demon-Haunted World", with his "invisible dragon in the garage" story.

The ability to do statistics at incredible scales (currently known as Machine Learning) raises further questions about what science should be. Questions about such quantitative methods themselves. Rigor does not have to be quantitative in nature -- and let's not forget that the very idea of quantitative science was introduced by Descartes, another famous philosopher.

> What people call useless is cruft dealing with Known Unknowable's which suck up time without getting anywhere.

Depends on where you want to get. Noncommunicable knowledge is a very interesting topic, for those with the inclination. It is ok if you are not curious about such things, but I would argue that it is also ok to be. It deeply intersects mathematical logic (e.g. Gödel) and theoretical computer science (e.g. the halting problem). Will it help us create better gadgets? Probably not? Will it help us better understand the human condition? Probably yes.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by Retric on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:22AM (#17154556)
Gödel is vast overkill. The list of things you can't compute with small finite amounts of processing power is vastly longer than the list of things you can't compute with infinite processing power.

AKA, Gödel is true but irreverent because it's not on the border of anything decidable. If you say the bonds are between 9^9 and 9↑↑↑↑9 that's just not useful.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by humanrebar on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:37PM (#17156666)
The general idea that certain statistical problems are intractible is fair though.

But we don't exactly discourage the idea that we will solve, say, nutrition some day.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by chrisweekly on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:40PM (#17160069)
>"Gödel is true but irreverent"

quite sure "irrelevant" is the intended word here. :)

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by pasabagi on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:34AM (#17154680)
I don't know where the idea that philsophy doesn't involve rigor and maths comes from. Leibniz came up with the entscheidung's problem, for god's sake! If you take the most basic interest in logic, maths, or even computers, you can't swing a cat without hitting a philosopher.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by Retric on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:55PM (#17155563)
I am referring to computation, not abstractions. What's the trade-off between X and Y is the kind of place where having some specific numbers is very helpful.

EX: At what point if any can you say testing theories on public data produces more value than noise.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:59PM (#17155629)
I'm having trouble seeing how any of that relates to your original comment or the responses to it. You said "[reasoning about what science is and does is part of philosophy] only if you approach Philosophy with a lot more rigor and math than what people have historically done." That comes across as a broad comment about levels of rigor in philosophy, not a comment on the usefulness of quantitative data in making trade-offs.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by Retric on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:32PM (#17156035)
"reasoning about what science is and does is part of philosophy."

I am saying some of that analysis benefits from real hard data. So, if your saying all of that analysis falls under philosophy, then I don't think that's what most people mean when the use the term.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:27PM (#17156563)
Sure, but philosophers usually do look at hard data where appropriate.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by pasabagi on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:40PM (#17157176)
I actually think 'hard data' is typically about as relevant to philosophy as it is to maths. Not everything is reducible to stats.

I just find it weird to be using a machine that's a recognizable descendant of the work of philosophers, as much as engineers or mathematicians, then to be saying casually that philosophy isn't rigorous.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by Retric on Saturday May 26, 2018 @05:47AM (#17161151)
You could argue using hard data is less rigorous. But, in practice people make mistakes so without verification Philosophy and math is again arguably less rigorous, depending on what you mean by that word.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by pasabagi on Saturday May 26, 2018 @01:18PM (#17163118)
Rigour is pretty hard to rigorously define. If we could, then epistemology would be complete.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:56PM (#17158342)
>I actually think 'hard data' is typically about as relevant to philosophy as it is to maths. Not everything is reducible to stats.

Oh yes, I agree entirely on that point.