Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by philwelch on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:11PM
(#17147865)
I think society values competence, and intelligence is a trait that enables, but does not guarantee, competence. There are a ton of highly intelligent people who do not hold high social status, because intelligence is neither necessary nor sufficient for competence. Highly intelligent people who never apply themselves to socially-valued aims are considered losers and hold zero status in our society; the archetypal example of this being Comic Book Guy from The Simpsons.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by tristor on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:34PM
(#17148156)
Yes, this is true. But I think it's more complex than this. Society /relies/ on competence for its continued existence, but it doesn't necessarily value it innately. Kind of referencing back to the person you replied to, the market values competence not society, but it does it out of necessity. Having competent people in all fields helps to accelerate your ability to grow, become profitable, and reduces mistakes.
The bulk of people in the West are apathetic without much care for their work, and care is nearly an inherent prerequisite of competence, as competence is something you develop and are not born with. You develop competence through focused practice and the care to understand. Clearly, while we rely on competence, it's not so highly valued.
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by kpil on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:52PM
(#17148301)
>The bulk of people in the West are apathetic without much care for their work
In my experience, most people put a lot of energy and care into their jobs, and most are proud over what they do even when they are not doing especially important or valued tasks.
They also seem to be putting the interest of the company above other concerns.