News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by wutbrodo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:55AM (#17141965)
> They either are mismanaged or are not willing to tell the users what data they are collecting and how they use and monetize this data. And it should worry all users, not only users from the EU.

I don't know a ton about GDPR, but the article makes it look like it has less to do with Instapaper (aside from risk tolerance) and more to do with the ambiguity of the law. Some relevant quotes:

> it’s more than likely to be the GDPR’s data subject access request, which allows any EU resident to request any and all data collected and stored about them. As The Verge reported yesterday, that’s causing companies trouble because it’s not entirely clear right now what information residents will request, what format that information needs to be in, how to locate it and package it, and whether new infrastructure needs to be created to manage this request pipeline. Personal info is a somewhat nebulous concept, and the fact that experts are describing the GDPR as “staggeringly complex” is not making it easy to cover all the bases.

> It’s clear that few companies, if any, will be 100 percent compliant when the law goes into effect. But because the fines are so steep — violating GDPR will cost a company 4 percent of its global turnover or $20 million, whichever is larger — no one really wants to be caught non-compliant. So that’s why companies are rushing and, in the case of Instapaper, literally shutting down.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by raverbashing on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:07AM (#17142300)
> it’s not entirely clear right now what information residents will request,

If they ask for something specific in an informal way, that can be provided

But from the GDPRs data portability point of view, it's everything that's linked to the account. Export your Facebook data for a good example of this.

HN example: it would be the information in your profile, the links/text you submitted (but not the content of the link itself), the comments (the comment IDs) you upvoted, stories flagged/upvoted (for the lenght of time this is kept, for example, if after a while user ids that upvoted a comment are erased and only the score is kept, that's fine) and maybe some other background information (for example: password hashes/access logs/etc)

> what format that information needs to be in,

Machine readable format. HTML/XML/JSON is fine.

> how to locate it and package it, and whether new infrastructure needs to be created to manage this request pipeline.

Well that's not the problem of the law, is it?

You know your data scheme. You know whether you can run this in your existing infrastructure or not.

    for TABLE in YOUR_TABLES
        SELECT * from TABLE where UserID == $user_id;
    end for
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by kodablah on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:12PM (#17147265)
From the HN example, does this include other comments that referenced my username? What about comments that might have linked to my GitHub profile? What if there are server logs that include my IP and a time which can correlate to when I posted a comment or something? What about this information on Algolia, must I contact them separately? Also, I wasn't aware...I can ask for my password hash? Can I request all of this information be deleted? (genuine questions btw assuming I were in the EU, not trolling)
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by raverbashing on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:37PM (#17147515)
Starting from the end

> Can I request all of this information be deleted?

Yes, the ones that are on HN. I'm not sure how it works for 3rd parties that obtain your data

> does this include other comments that referenced my username?

I don't think so, this is unlikely, especially as you didn't create it and HN doesn't link this (as opposed to reddit)

> What about comments that might have linked to my GitHub profile?

I'd say that being required is even less likely as HN has no way of knowing what's your GH profile

GDPR is what they know about you. If they're actively trying to link pasted GH profiles and usernames then this would apply, otherwise no.

> What if there are server logs that include my IP and a time which can correlate to when I posted a comment or something?

That thing with IPs being PII I'd say this would apply, but then again, this doesn't bring any new information.

So if they keep track of users access times then yes, but if this information is rotated, sent to /dev/null then no.

You're not obligated to connect all the dots, or track user login times. That being said, IP (especially + times) are PII so better anonymize it and discard once not needed.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by shabble on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:32PM (#17149078)
> for table in tables: select * from table where ...

Arguably much or all of the entries with FKs to those rows as well, transitively. Unless you don't believe in normalisation :)

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by raverbashing on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:17AM (#17150809)
Yes, you are correct!

(I'll leave the normalization debate for later :) )

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by TomK32 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:09AM (#17142038)
An email-address to send requests to and someone setting up a process for those requests along with a definition of which data to be returned to the user, all that isn't hard to implement. GDPR has caused some panic that's unnecessary.

The violations won't be fined with 4%/€20m (€ not $) right away, there's more steps before that, starting with "a warning in writing in cases of first and non-intentional noncompliance"

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by brownbat on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:08AM (#17142301)
> GDPR has caused some panic that's unnecessary.

Maybe some companies have overreacted, but dismissing them feels a bit like blaming the user for bad UX.

Couldn't you argue that a law that causes a panicked overreaction was a poorly written law in at least one respect, given that laws have a communicative function?

Especially if all these complaints were raised well in advance of the passage of the law, so that the drafters had plenty of warning that several groups were struggling to understand the text?

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by TomK32 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:12PM (#17147264)
The regulation was in the making since 2012. Plenty of time I'd say https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regula...

The german Wikipedia has a lot more details on the history and development of the regulation: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datenschutz-Grundverordnung

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by DanBC on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:57AM (#17151261)
Seems pretty clear to me that a lot is taken into account and that the regulators can't go straight to huge fines.

https://gdpr-info.eu/art-83-gdpr/

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by djhworld on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:02AM (#17141999)
What...data are they collecting?

It's a site that pins articles people have saved, the only piece of user data they should hold would be email address and maybe IP address? Simple to put in policies to expire the IP address data after a reasonable amount of time.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by bthdonohue on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:21AM (#17142096)
We detail the types of information we collect and how we use the data in our privacy policy here: https://www.instapaper.com/privacy
Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by dmitriid on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:10PM (#17148441)
If that's the only info you collect, it would take you way less than two years to get compliant with GDPR.

So there's something you're not telling.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by oldcynic on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:15AM (#17142070)
> because the fines are so steep — violating GDPR will cost a company

Will? The usual misinformation then.

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by seba_dos1 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:15AM (#17143638)
> violating GDPR will cost a company 4 percent of its global turnover or $20 million, whichever is larger

You forgot "up to, depending of severity of violation".

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by thisisit on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:16AM (#17142077)
>> violating GDPR will cost a company 4 percent of its global turnover or $20 million, whichever is larger

Isn't there a lower level - 2% and $10 million too?

https://www.itgovernance.co.uk/dpa-and-gdpr-penalties

Re:Instapaper is temporarily shutting off access for Europea... by sgift on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:44AM (#17142214)
There are various lower levels. It's "up to". Many of the things GDPR requires have been law in various parts of Europe for a long time (e.g. Germany), sometimes in all of Europe. But the fines were so low that most companies said "eh, who cares" - now enforcement has teeth and it's panic all around.