Where Apple fails miserably is search, and local place names. Apple Maps data will often show results in a different country instead of whatever I meant to search for in my city. Trying to find businesses if you don’t know the full official names is practically impossible.
Apple Maps works great if you know the official address, but it’s pretty much useless for anything else.
It's still not quite up there with Google Map's location knowledge, but it's certainly not the often-innacurate mess it once was.
The big difference I see now days comes down to how quickly the data is updated. To test this, take a newly opened (or closed) restaurant or store and compare Apple and Google's knowledge of the location.
Google tends to have it almost immediately, presumably because Google provides tools for the business owners to enter the information directly. But Apple's knowledge can lag behind by a few weeks, or more for more obscure things. This is presumably due to their dependence on third-party data providers like Yelp.
It will just do crazy stuff. Ask for something and want you to drive, literally, to something 300 miles away. It is easily confused when you use something by it's name.
But trying to use Apple Maps on holiday in Europe was almost useless.
Then so many other things. Google Maps will tell you if the place will be open or closed when you will get there for example.
Apple use to stand for providing the best products. The best user experience. Somehow that has been lost and become acceptable to do a poor job.
Same with Siri. It is just an awful user experience compared to using the Google Assistant.
Guess my question is why is this acceptable? Look at their privacy agreement and you approve them collecting all kinds of data so that is not it. Heck Apple even forces you to accept them collecting data on people you interact with in the US.
https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/
"When you share your content with family and friends using Apple products, send gift certificates and products, or invite others to participate in Apple services or forums, Apple may collect the information you provide about those people such as name, mailing address, email address, and phone number. Apple will use such information to fulfill your requests, provide the relevant product or service, or for anti-fraud purposes."
I am tired of Apple getting a pass on offering a poor user experience. What they use to be all about.
Also, with regards to the blog link, why would you care about how detailed the buildings on the map are for daily use? And Google will tell me if something will be closed by the time I get there. But it's usually wrong for me.
I remember when Apple approach was to be the best.
To be fair to Apple, tehy are very responsive if you report. I quite often use the in-Map tool for reporting a problem with a location and these days get a 'Its been fixed' within a few days or a week.
It has now been long enough for them to get it better and worries me that it is just now acceptable at Apple.
Siri is nowhere near as bad as you suggest. You are exaggerating to make a point.
https://amp.businessinsider.com/images/59309194b74af426208b5...
Assistant is all about UX and the Apple of the past would do everything they could to be the best. I mean way better versus so far behind.
They have had plenty of time now to make Apple Maps better. Here is a great comparison.
https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-moat/
Why is this acceptable?
> Apple of the past would do everything they could to be the best.
Sigh... Which Apple? Scott? Jobs I/Markkula? Sculley? Spindler? Amelio? Jobs II? You are aware that this all started before 2007? The Performa series, released under Spindlers watch, were arguably the lowest point in Apple's history. So let's not get too hyperbolic about the state of Siri, which is considerably better than you allude to. As to accuracy, Google links into the biggest search engine in the world, and Google seem to be ethically challenged when examining that data.
> They have had plenty of time now to make Apple Maps better. Here is a great comparison.
That is subjective. Objectively, Apples maps are significantly better than they were upon release 6 years ago. As I already pointed out, Google have a 7 year head start in an area that is neither parties core business, so good enough is all they need to be. Google Maps are useless to me as they cannot find my address. Apple maps can. For me, in and around London, Apple's maps have been objectively better than Googles. YMMV.
As to the article; building footprints make for better mapping? That's, like, your opinion man...
They strived to provide the best UX.
It is very disappointing to see.
http://macdailynews.com/2018/02/22/apple-maps-vs-google-maps...
>“Relative to Google Maps, Apple Maps estimated trip times were on average 8% longer (i.e worse) and Waze estimates are 3% shorter (i.e. better),” Grabowski writes. “Using Apple Maps, I on average arrived 1% faster than initially estimated, versus 2% slower with Google Maps and 11% slower with Waze. In other words, Apple sandbags its estimates so that users on average arrive at the predicted time or slightly sooner. Google and Waze are overly optimistic in their predictions and thus their users arrive later than expected.”
Depends on where you are. Goole maps are surprisingly poor in parts of London.
For some reason it is now acceptable to provide a bad user experience and Apple Maps is a perfect example compared to Waze or Google Maps. But the gap is increasing.
It is the same with Siri. So will it be acceptable if an Apple self driving cars kills people?
I just do not get the excuses for Apple? Why have they moved from what they use to stand for?
https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/
Apple has the ability to collect all the same data as Google but actually more. Apple actually forces you to agree to them collecting data on people you interact with.
I quote from the agreement.
"When you share your content with family and friends using Apple products, send gift certificates and products, or invite others to participate in Apple services or forums, Apple may collect the information you provide about those people such as name, mailing address, email address, and phone number. "
https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/
I get Apple is great at marketing but lets work in reality.
My issue is NOT that the Apple services are sub par but rather when did it become acceptable at Apple to have second rate user experiences?
Why are they given a pass?
https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/
Heck they can collect who you associate with. I quote from the document.
"When you share your content with family and friends using Apple products, send gift certificates and products, or invite others to participate in Apple services or forums, Apple may collect the information you provide about those people such as name, mailing address, email address, and phone number. "
Historically been a big Apple hardware user but have to admit less and less. Most being replaced by Google hardware. Do carry both a Pixel 2 XL and a iPhone now as just could wait no longer for Apple to fix their products.
Replaced my Mac with a Pixel Book also for example. As well as our AirPort Extremes with Google WiFi.
I find it baffling that it is now acceptable to have poor products. The Apple that I loved for so many years NEVER settled for being good enough.
Some of your examples make sense but why replace your Airport with a (data mining built-in) Google WiFi? Why not a known good provider like e.g. Ubiquiti? I use their Amplifi and it works great, no "cloud" crap and their brand is reputable.
https://policies.google.com/privacy/update
As you can see Google agreement in reality is more limited than Apple. Google does not collect personal data from people you interact with that have not agreed like Apple.
That was my point.
BTW, have Google WiFi and a fantastic product. Replaced our AirPort Extremes and highly recommend.
What I also love is Google provides a dashboard on everything they collect all in one place and you can remove or download if you want. I am in the US and really wish Apple would provide the same transparency as Google.
I tend to be for little government but if Apple is not going to do it on their own like Google then think government should consider forcing them to.
Headlines like
“Apple TV service will share viewing data with networks, report claims”
Read more at http://www.trustedreviews.com/news/apple-tv-service-will-sha...
Is really bothersome with Apple. I would like the ability to instead remove my data so they can not share it.
Plus still really bothers me that Apple handed over all their user data in China to the government.
"Campaign targets Apple over privacy betrayal for Chinese iCloud users"
https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/03/apple-privacy...
Versus Google decided to leave China instead of giving up their users data.
I am more into the facts versus narratives and marketing.
> We collect information about your activity in our services, which we use to do things like recommend a YouTube video you might like. The activity information we collect may include:
And within that list is:
> People with whom you communicate or share content
I think this one little bullet point is way more vague than Apples and less limiting.
Apple privacy agreement allows them to collect data on my wife, kids and others I interact with.
I am pretty OK with my data being at Google. But NOT ok with data being collected from people I interact with.
Then on top Google has their dashboard in the US with everything they collect in one place and the ability to remove or download.
We have nothing like it in the US with Apple and that really bothers me. What data do they have on my kids or friends since I interact with them?
I carry both an iPhone and a Pixel 2 XL. But several of my kids have iPhones so when on holiday will share my location in iMessages but have no idea what Apple is doing with the data. No transparency like Google.
Then the entire thing where Apple handed all their customer data over to the China government have a huge issue with. I like Google approach where the China government tried to hack Gmail accounts and Google indicated not acceptable and left the country.
Seems like Apple was willing to give up their users data for the mighty buck.
To be clear I do NOT think it is acceptable to be collecting data on people I interact with! These people should be able to control if their data is collected and their control of it getting collected should be respected!
Some might not want Apple collecting it and I should never get to say it is OK for others.
My brother for example is very, very against any company having his data. He does not use an iPhone. Do not think he uses any Apple products.
None of this is a reflection on Apple's abilities in Data Science in which they've done some outstanding work on with (a) differential privacy with iOS and (b) FaceID.
And just because the Maps and Siri teams have issues of there own doesn't mean Apple has to stop everything they are doing until it is fixed. They can walk and chew gum at the same time.