News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by lmm on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:19PM (#17139373)
I must admit I don't entirely understand how your approach works, but it seems like it requires all the functions you want to use in transactions to live on MyTransaction (even if only as extension methods)? I want to be able to write normal functions including quite high-level ones that take some business objects and return MustHappenInTransaction[SomeOtherBusinessObject], and pass these return values through generic methods that don't know anything about transactions specifically.
Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by kllrnohj on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:02PM (#17139650)

    typealias MustBeInTransaction = MyTransaction.() -> Unit
    
    fun makeObject(i: Int): MustBeInTransaction {
        return { /* do something with i or whatever in a transaction */ }
    }
    
    fun test() {
        var genericArray = arrayOf(1, 2, 3).map { makeObject(it) }
        //genericArray.forEach { it() } // fails to compile
        transaction {
            genericArray.forEach { it() }
        }
    }
Like that?
Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by eeperson on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:43PM (#17140622)
It just dawned on me that Kotlin receivers[1] and extension methods[2] are basically the equivalent to Scala implicit params and conversions respectively. Although it appears that receivers can only really be used with anonymous functions. This appears to be similar to implicit function types proposed for Dotty[3]. So the Dotty equivalent to the above would be:

    type MustBeInTransaction = implicit MyTransaction => Unit

    def makeObject(i: Int): MustBeInTransaction = {
        return { /* do something with i or whatever in a transaction */ }
    }
    
    def test(): Unit = {
        var genericArray = Array(1, 2, 3).map(makeObject)
        //genericArray.forEach { _() } // fails to compile
        transaction {
            genericArray.forEach { _() }
        }
    }
EDIT - I just noticed that this is almost exactly the same as the example used in the function types link below

[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/45875491/what-is-a-recei...

[2] https://kotlinlang.org/docs/reference/extensions.html

[3] https://www.scala-lang.org/blog/2016/12/07/implicit-function...

Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by eeperson on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:59AM (#17143117)
It is interesting to see that is possible in Kotlin. I just learned a lot about receivers (as an aside, do you know where I can find better documentation? The best I could find was a stack overflow post).

I think this issue with this is what happens when you combine DB transactions with async queries with errors and null handling? It seems like you have to combine 4 different mechanisms in order to do this (receivers, async/await, try/catch, if(null)). Is there some way to do this all with receivers? It seems like they don't really compose.

The 'command' version in Scala could be written roughly the same way for any combination of the 4 features (the types would just change). For example you could write a Scala version of your original example as:

    def test(): Unit = {
        // update() compiles but doesn't do anything to the DB
        val helloDBOperation = for {
            _ <- query()
            _ <- update()
            _ <- query2()
        } yield "Hello"
        
        val hello = db.run(helloDBOperation)
        println("$hello") // prints "Hello"
    }
This would look almost exactly the same no matter which combination of the 4 features you use.

EDIT - it looks like I somehow also accidentally replied to you with an earlier version of this comment. Unfortunately , I didn't notice until it was too old to delete or edit. Please ignore the other comment that is very similar to this one. Sorry about the confusion.

Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by kllrnohj on Thursday May 24, 2018 @01:40PM (#17146373)
> as an aside, do you know where I can find better documentation? The best I could find was a stack overflow post

https://kotlinlang.org/docs/reference/type-safe-builders.htm...

It's more designed to build DSLs or similar, so you'll find more documentaion/examples in that area of the docs.

> I think this issue with this is what happens when you combine DB transactions with async queries with errors and null handling? It seems like you have to combine 4 different mechanisms in order to do this (receivers, async/await, try/catch, if(null)). Is there some way to do this all with receivers? It seems like they don't really compose.

It's just a closure with a compiler-added paremeter. It can be nullable if you want and exceptions work the same as any other closure. If you want async/await you'd use coroutines. I think coroutines and receivers mix just fine, you'd just make the type a suspending lambda with receiver, but I've never tried.

Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by eeperson on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:14PM (#17147278)
> https://kotlinlang.org/docs/reference/type-safe-builders.htm.... > > It's more designed to build DSLs or similar, so you'll find more documentaion/examples in that area of the docs.

Thanks for the link. However, I feel like that still doesn't give a lot of detail. Can you have multiple receivers? Can receivers be generic? Can receiver resolution be controlled by other arguments?

> It's just a closure with a compiler-added paremeter. It can be nullable if you want and exceptions work the same as any other closure. If you want async/await you'd use coroutines. I think coroutines and receivers mix just fine, you'd just make the type a suspending lambda with receiver, but I've never tried

Sorry I didn't mean to imply that Kotlin was incapable expressing all of these things together. I meant it would be desirable to express all of these things with the same tools. It seems like the you would have to express these with several different paradigms and be aware of how they interact. That also means you would need more boilerplate because you have to abstract each of these things separately.

Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by eeperson on Thursday May 24, 2018 @04:00AM (#17141987)
It is interesting to see that is possible in Kotlin. I just learned a lot about receivers (as an aside, do you know where I can find better documentation? The best I could find was a stack overflow post).

I think this issue with this is what happens when you combine DB transactions with async queries with errors and null handling? It seems like you have to combine 4 different mechanisms in order to do this (receivers, async/await, try/catch, if(null)). Is there some way to do this all with receivers? It seems like they don't really compose.

The 'command' version in Scala could be written roughly the same way for any combination of the 4 features (the types would just change). For example you could write your original example as:

    def test() {
        // update() compiles but doesn't do anything to the DB
        val helloDBOperation = for {
            result1 <- query()
            _ <- update()
            result2 <- query2()
        } yield "Hello"
        

        println("$hello") // prints "Hello"
    }
Re:From Java to Kotlin and Back Again by lmm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:32AM (#17143775)
Yeah, like that. But if code like that is permitted, is there anything that stops me writing a method that stashes a MyTransaction.() in a variable and then using it in another method long after the transaction it's supposed to represent has been closed?