News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by jgh on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:56PM (#17138732)
I'm not sure why the article is speculating about a "seismic" change. Apple (and Microsoft and Google have followed) has established a pattern for their OS evolution: yearly incremental updates.
Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by jedberg on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:00PM (#17138759)
They had established that same pattern before too, until they released MacOS X and created a seismic change.

What the author is saying is that we should be coming up on a new chip for the Mac pretty soon, and if history is any guide, we may also be upon a brand new OS.

That being said, I don't think we'll see seismic shift, unless you count the possible unification of iOS and MacOS a seismic shift.

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by philwelch on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:37PM (#17139072)
While Mac OS 9 -> Mac OS X was a seismic shift, the System 6 -> System 7, System 7 -> Mac OS 8, and to some extent, Mac OS 8 -> Mac OS 9 transitions were significantly more than just "incremental" updates.
Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by drb91 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:28PM (#17138986)
> we should be coming up on a new chip for the Mac pretty soon, and if history is any guide, we may also be upon a brand new OS.

If anything, I would interpret this to mean that a new OS is further off than the chip--the transition from 68k to PPC was not accompanied by a major OS change; that came with OSX several years later. Same with the transition from PPC to x86: snow leopard was notoriously "boring", and we're still on an os distinctly similar to snow leopard.

Meanwhile, both iOS and ARM were borne out of necessity. I'm not sure how to figure them into predictions of the future here.

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by linguae on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:53PM (#17139191)
It's possible for a hypothetical transition from x86 to a new architecture to be accompanied with an OS change. Had Pink/Taligent been completed as originally planned, then the transition from the 68k to the PowerPC would have been accompanied by a transition from System 7 to Pink/Taligent. Part of the reason that IBM got involved with the development of Taligent was the AIM (Apple/IBM/Motorola) alliance, which was formed in 1991 and led to the PowerPC transition.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taligent

Unfortunately the development efforts of Taligent failed, which led to the equally-doomed Copland project, which led to Apple's purchase of NeXT. This saga lasted around a decade.

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by drb91 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:06PM (#17139266)
Hey, great info! Wasn't aware of that, and it definitely changes the substance of my comment above.
Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by Infernal on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:01PM (#17138771)
From the article: "I doubt we will see a seismic transition to a new Mac OS"

This doesn't feel like the same speculation that you read?

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by pier25 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:00PM (#17139641)
Incremental updates only work up to a certain point.

I imagine Apple is working on its universal OS for all its devices, but maybe waiting for the switch to ARM on desktop.

Google is working on Fuchsia to apply all it has learned from Android and Chrome OS. I think it will be a hit. Google has got really good at making products for users and devs alike, but Android is a mess because it was never written from scratch.

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by linguae on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:40PM (#17139097)
When Steve Jobs announced the transition from the PowerPC to the x86 architecture in 2005, he mentioned that the transition from Mac OS 9 to Mac OS X which took place between 2001 and 2003 set Apple up for the next 20 years.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghdTqnYnFyg

It's 2018, 20 years since Apple first announced Mac OS X at WWDC 1998 as a change from their original Rhapsody strategy. The 20th anniversary of the actual release of Mac OS X for consumers is approaching in a few years.

Now, I still believe that there is plenty of life in Mac OS X, and I could see it easily being usable at least throughout the 2020s, provided that Apple maintains it in the meanwhile.

However, I definitely wouldn't mind a new desktop OS. Let's face it: modern desktops such as Windows, Mac OS X, GNOME and its derivatives like Cinnamon, and KDE are all based on the GUI paradigm developed at Xerox PARC for the Xerox Alto workstation. This paradigm was further developed by Apple for the Lisa and the original Macintosh, and it has been further refined by NeXTSTEP, Windows 95, and early versions of Mac OS X. However, there are other GUI paradigms that haven't been tried in desktop environments outside of research labs and niche environments. For example, Xerox PARC also developed the Smalltalk environment. While it is commonly thought of as a programming language, it is more than just that; it is an operating system running inside a VM where everything is an object. This environment could easily be used to write full-fledged applications that also support message passing through a REPL. It is possible to build a system of GUI applications that are scriptable and composable through Smalltalk's message passing system, thus combining the usability advantages of contemporary GUI applications with the power of the command line.

There are other features that we don't have yet that can be added to a new operating system. For example, we came close to having a database file system available for the desktop when Microsoft was working on WinFS over a decade ago, but unfortunately it was cancelled in order to get Windows Vista shipped faster. Having a semantically-rich file system would be a very nice thing.

At the same time, though, given that the iOS platform is Apple's major revenue stream, I am concerned that the days of the Mac are numbered. I feel it is Apple's dream for everyone to be using the closed-down iOS instead of a general-purpose OS such as macOS. I feel Apple has been preparing pro Mac users for this transition by deliberately neglecting the Mac Mini and Mac Pro lines and by turning the MacBook Pro into basically an expensive, "blinged-out" MacBook Air Plus, signaling to pro users that the future of Apple won't include them (although the announcement of the 2019 Mac Pro might be contrary to this view).

All of this is to say that I would not be surprised if we see a new OS from Apple within the next five years, but I'm concerned that instead of seeing the next step of general purpose desktop computing, we're going to see a scaled-up version of iOS instead, which would be disappointing, especially if general purpose desktop computing is relegated to Windows and desktop Linux. I'm of the opinion that we do need another non-Apple general-purpose desktop OS, at least to hedge our bets in case Apple goes all-iOS and to avoid the situation where Microsoft has a monopoly on commercial general-purpose desktop operating systems.

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by scroot on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:09AM (#17144725)
Someone is eventually going to make one of the systems you describe, regardless of what Apple does. Modern consumer OSes are overly complex. Worse, there's nothing "personal" about personal computing. Something like a Smalltalk machine would go a long way, so long as it was built on appropriate metaphors and allowed users to "peel back" layers at a time as they wished to do more (imagine a system that, at the top user layer, acts like a "hypercard machine," but is Smalltalk or something underneath).

The proliferation of Internet access has changed the game in this regard. Back in the 80s and early 90s, compatibility issues among exotic PC systems led people to adopt only several types. But now as long as you can communicate and your system has a web browser...

Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by mediocrejoker on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:16PM (#17139363)
Maybe if Apple kills their general purpose desktop enough designers will migrate to Linux and decide to improve the desktop UX there. It's perhaps unlikely but one can dream.
Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by sebnap on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:14PM (#17139346)
Beautifully said. I imagine a unix that works out of the box like a general purpose macOS.
Re:OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out by sebnap on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:17PM (#17138902)
Regarding: "I doubt we will see a seismic transition to a new Mac OS"

First of all, you can observe a drop-off in quality (-control) with every new upgrade. OSes should be stable and not layered with new destabilising os-features every year. Since Tim Cook took over, the apple products were mere Box'es and not new new internets. I don't think they will come up with something "seismic" big.