Re:Apple Avoids Amazon’s Beauty Contest, Searches Secretly f...
by closeparen on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:32PM
(#17140879)
Seattle did not fall from the sky. These arguments were presumably valid at every phase of its growth. What’s special about now?
Re:Apple Avoids Amazon’s Beauty Contest, Searches Secretly f...
by vkou on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:49AM
(#17145165)
It's more expensive to build the same infrastructure today then it was in 1960 for a huge number of reasons, none of which have anything to do with Seattle policy.
As density increased, the infrastructure we need today is more expensive, even if the cost of construction stayed the same.
Before all land within city limits was developed, the city could charge large fees for subdivisions. Generally, American city infrastructure is financed by such fees. There aren't very many subdivisions happening anymore.
Lastly, the rate of population growth was slower, and did not create a housing crisis. All of the above can be stomached through when you don't have exploding rents and homeless populations -despite the unprecedented levels of residential construction the city's seeing.
The share of property taxes that Amazon, and its employees pay do not cover the costs of building out new infrastructure to support them. It's basic mathematics.
Let's say that you and four of your friends live in a 5-bedroom house. Let's say that you all pay an equal share of rent, maintenance, etc. Let's say that I decide to move into your house...
And demand that we knock down an exterior wall, and build a sixth bedroom, and a second bathroom, to accommodate me (Because everyone needs a bedroom! And one bathroom doesn't cut it for 6 people - it barely supported 5!) And insist that all six of us split the cost of this construction equally.
You should be happy about this - the rent-payer base has increased! Now a sixth person is chipping into paying the groundskeeper to mow the lawn. Never mind the $83,333 construction bill that the five of you had to front.
It's bollocks, and it's the situation Seattle is currently in. Existing residents are expected to pick up the tab for new people moving into their neighbourhoods. Yes, taxable activity is rising faster then the cost of population, but so is the infrastructure bill. It's a lot cheaper to maintain a five-bedroom house in a steady-state, then to build an extra bedroom in it. It's a lot cheaper to maintain the city's existing infrastructure, then to expand it to meet this population growth.
The only solution is making it extremely expensive to upzone commercial spaces (Which will result in shenanigans - like packing more employees into less space), or by taxing tech firms directly.