Re:The demise of r/science AMAs on Reddit
by masklinn on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @03:37PM
(#17137414)
> Why do moderators need tools to promote content they view as valuable? Isn't that what the upvote button is for?
The upvote button leads to Logan Paul and walmart. If that's what you want, there are plenty of unmoderated subreddits which provide that.
> These are moderators. Volunteer enthusiasts of the communities they moderate. They have no stake in Reddit and they get nothing regardless of what content gets seen by who.
They absolutely have a stake in the community they are nurturing actually working and leading towards the outcome they're looking for. Folks moderating /r/science want /r/science to be good according to their criteria of goodness, which are unlikely to be the same criteria used by moderators of /r/aww, /r/antm, /r/SWARJE/ or /r/SubredditSimulator/, all of which are different from one another.
Moderators are not unemotional robots doing busywork for a faceless corporation.
> They're job is to make sure nobody breaks subreddit rules.
Their "job" is to create and foster communities, moderators define subreddit rules in the first place.
The upvote button leads to Logan Paul and walmart. If that's what you want, there are plenty of unmoderated subreddits which provide that.
> These are moderators. Volunteer enthusiasts of the communities they moderate. They have no stake in Reddit and they get nothing regardless of what content gets seen by who.
They absolutely have a stake in the community they are nurturing actually working and leading towards the outcome they're looking for. Folks moderating /r/science want /r/science to be good according to their criteria of goodness, which are unlikely to be the same criteria used by moderators of /r/aww, /r/antm, /r/SWARJE/ or /r/SubredditSimulator/, all of which are different from one another.
Moderators are not unemotional robots doing busywork for a faceless corporation.
> They're job is to make sure nobody breaks subreddit rules.
Their "job" is to create and foster communities, moderators define subreddit rules in the first place.