Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by merinowool on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @12:50PM
(#17135656)
Law is terrible because after two years people still don't know what to do and how to be complaint. There is as many interpretations as interpreters and so on. GDPR is a tool to shut down websites under guise of protecting privacy.
Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by quadrangle on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @01:44PM
(#17136228)
Oh come on. Hanlon's Razor.
GDPR, like all laws, has something to do with power struggles. But do you have evidence supporting your doubt that it's actually intended to be about protecting citizen privacy?
Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by merinowool on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @04:30PM
(#17137966)
This has opened so many attack vectors than it closed. For example you no longer need to hack a database to get user data. Just impersonate and request the data from target company. Cookie law trained people to click anything without reading and people don't understand what they do online. Then data portability will enable more pii in circulation. For example fake social network enables Facebook account import for prizes and so on. Now GDPR emails train people to mindlessly signup and agree to whatever. Just create fake email asking to sign up to copy of a target site. Obtain password and download all data. Furthermore employees will have easy access to neatly packaged user data, so that they can sell it in the site. This law is hackers wet dream.
Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by quadrangle on Saturday May 26, 2018 @06:07PM
(#17164501)
Indeed, there may be really negative consequences of incompetence. But understanding when it's incompetence versus malice is still useful perspective.
Given that protectionism is stupid and protectionists genuinely believe that they are doing something good for their nation when they implement protectionist policies I can use Hanlon's razor and assume both.
Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by quadrangle on Saturday May 26, 2018 @06:09PM
(#17164509)
"protectionism is stupid" can be used as a generality, but if you make it a broad, confident assertion you're removing human judgment and trying to apply simplistic rules to the world — which is exactly the type of thinking that makes bureaucracies stupid.
And yes, with Hanlon's Razor, you can still criticize things that you accept as likely coming from good intentions.
Isn't that mostly because, despite being given 2 years to implement, nobody's really bothered to do anything until the last second?
Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by merinowool on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:09PM
(#17138317)
If it is unclear what to do, then why would anyone risk doing it wrong?
If you start out early, you can contact your country's regulator for guidance.
Re:No one’s ready for GDPR
by merinowool on Thursday May 24, 2018 @03:08AM
(#17141702)
Which are not going to know either, because it is all free to interpretation. It is not uncommon that even when government offers paid interpretation, so that company can back what they do by it, to withdraw it couple years later and fine the company (Because civil servant giving out the interpretation was wrong or for other reasons).
Since it applies quite a few new rules that pertain to the development of software, many of which do not store data that is that interesting. (Things like the usual user and IP address logging used to fight spammers.)
So the result is that developing software is more complicated and expensive, and hence less services that people want to use (and only services people want to use matter) come into existence, leading to a lower quality of life.
I don't buy that last sentence for a single second. Fewer services not caring about your data is not a bad thing. And those that do pop up will have done so in an age of caring about user data, thus leading to higher quality services, and a higher quality of life.
Hell, something like this should have been instituted from the very start of the internet.
SOT: As for Brexit - I'm very curious how it would turn out, especially with so many conflict points (Ireland border and Scots wanting referendum for example)