News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK ISPs have to stop lying about broadband speeds by tialaramex on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:30AM (#17134939)
Yup. To invoke the inevitable car analogy, if your problem is it takes too long to get to 40mph from a standing start at the lights, upgrading from 200mph to 250mph top speed won't necessarily help. Even more so if the problem is sometimes it won't start on a cold morning or there aren't enough seats.

The pro-fibre lobby is convinced that somehow 1Gbps will enable an as yet undetermined application and countries where people have 40Mbps will get left behind. But the application doesn't exist. I had 1Gbps for several years, now I have 40Mbps. It's not just that I don't miss it, I don't even notice. I could easily afford faster, but I could also easily afford a giant cardboard Han Solo, and I didn't buy that either.

Reliability matters, but in practice copper reliability isn't bad enough to be a significant factor compared to consumer gear.

Latency matters, but most of the work needed there is in consumer gear, not in the last mile or elsewhere in ISP networks.

There are no comments on this comment yet.