Have you actually done this? Because I have, and even after telling them, "I'm paying for 25 down and using your modem I'm barely pulling down 7." Their suggestion was that I should upgrade to 50 down.
I told them to go to Hell and switched to Fios.
Unless you hook the modem directly up to the cable coming from the pole/ground then they can always blame the cabling in your house.
Even when Comcast sends a tech out to your house to punch holes in the walls, floor, and ceiling to install cables they don't guarantee that install.
I had an issue years ago and Comcast insisted it was an issue with my house cabling and refused to do anything but send a tech out at my expense. When he knocked on the door I lead him around to the side of my house where the cable came down from the pole. I had my modem sitting there on a bucket plugged into that cable and an extension cord powering it. It wasn't until I showed him with my laptop plugged directly into the Ethernet port that it wasn't establishing a signal lock that they sent a bucket truck out to inspect the lines and fix the problem.
I'd happily cough up the cost of router rental for this ability, but I never seem to get it. With my own router, support calls stonewall when the rep blames my router. Without it, they persist a little longer and then generally shrug and say they have no further solutions and it's probably a temporary issue.
I'm used to getting 1/2 of the speed I pay for, that's happened with every ISP I've ever had, but lately Comcast has been moving down towards 1/5 and raising prices. I'd be willing to go back to a rented router to get that fixed, but at the moment it looks like their retention department will be my best hope.
Tell them you want to cancel. You'll be routed to the cancellation department, which is greatly empowered and incentivized to ensure you don't cancel. I have to do this about once a year, when Spectrum/TWC randomly adds $40 to my monthly internet bill.
What is this, the dark ages? o.o
In my experience that was when they'd point out that their advertisements only say “up to x speed” and lie that the server I was trying to use must be overloaded. The best answer is to contact your local government regulators and/or switch to the competition.
We had Comcast in New Haven and when we moved to DC the experience had left me soured enough that I got 8Mb DSL rather than deal with Comcast again. In the evenings, the DSL line reliably delivered better performance than our Comcast service had. We subsequently moved to a neighborhood with RCN and the experience has been night and day different: if I pay for 50Mb, I get 50Mb.
You can still make that argument by plugging a computer directly into the modem. It's not a good idea for long term use as there is no NAT so your computer will directly receive all traffic for your public IP but it's fine for the initial setup when you're verifying that your supposed “up to X MB/s" is really "barely Y MB/s".
In my case, I was on my own modem on Comcast, my new service on my new ISP is using DOCSIS 3.1, and what they support at what speeds seems to be changing frequently, so a rental is the safest bet right now. (And 3.1 modems are expensive as heck.) I tried buying one, it was too new for my ISP to work with, and all the other ones both cost more and were lower end hardware. I'll probably switch back to my own modem once 3.1 stabilizes a bit.