Re:Copyright will bring the end of ownership
by mbyrne on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @09:43AM
(#1712531)
You have a point, but it is more accurate to say that government is established by people to enforce their concept of ownership amongst themselves. Government isn't source of the concept of ownership, it is the enforcer of that society's concept of ownership.
Having said that, I advocate that there is a overarching source of ownership rights, whether they are called moral rights or natural rights or whatever. For example, I think a person owns his own body and regardless of what the law says, the government can't visit your house and take one of your kidneys because someone else wants yours. Other people think that they should be able to, for the "good" of society.
Re:Copyright will bring the end of ownership
by billybob on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @12:08PM
(#1713092)
I agree with you, but people who claim not to believe in moral absolutes, such as "it is wrong to steal someone's kidneys even if the law says you can," really should never protest any law, copyright or otherwise, except to say "I don't personally like that." To say "it's unjust" is to make a claim that, in their philosophy, means nothing.
Of course, as a Christian, I believe we're endowed by our Creator with certain unalienable rights...
To be fair, a court could probably also order the police to come to your house and confiscate your paper books. In that sense, you really don't own anything - ownership is a product of governments. (Or rather, a product of guns).