News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by mrfusion on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:16PM (#17122612)
I thought a wider wings would cause more drag? What am I missing?
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by kgilpin on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:55PM (#17122801)
You’ll be interested to read about aspect ratio: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect_ratio_(aeronautics)

As the ratio of the span to the chord increases, the ratio of lift to drag increases as well.

The drag of an object in the sense of forcing its way through the air (eg a semi truck on the highway) is important, but for airplanes there is also a very important phenomenon of drag due to lift (“induced drag”). It’s kind of non-intuitive. But if you’ve ever seen those strong vortices coming off a wingtip, you’re seeing induced drag. Think of the energy creating this: https://youtu.be/uXrnGiIMGLs

It’s energy created by propulsion but turned uselessly into spinning air.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by phumbe on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:03PM (#17122844)
You beat me by two minutes on the aspect ratio bit :)

Here's another good video showing wingtip vortices: https://www.instagram.com/p/BhzCLgFnVzL/?hl=en&taken-by=edse...

Not sure what you mean by "energy created by propulsion." The vortices result from low pressure on top and high pressure below making the air want to curl around. That imparts downwash on the wing, reducing its effectiveness.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by kgilpin on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:13PM (#17122894)
I mean that the airplane’s propulsion system is ultimately the power source behind those vortices, by forcing the wing through the stationary air.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by theothermkn on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:12PM (#17122891)
As sailplane pilots point out, TINSFS (There is no substitute for span.)

By far, for wings of reasonable aspect ratio, induced drag is much larger than parasitic drag contributions for a wing. It's really only when you get down into the relatively soupy flow around hobby RC sailplanes that you're meaningfully constrained by skin friction. Let me explain.

The coefficients of lift and drag for wing sections are idealized, resulting from wind tunnel tests where the section spans the tunnel. This makes them effectively infinite in span, since there are no spanwise differences in the flow characteristics; All flow proceeds from the upstream direction, laterally parallel, over (and under) the section, and then down the end of the tunnel.

Real wings, however, are finite in length. While there are a number of ways to think about what happens at the wing tip, not the worst is to say that high pressure air from under the wing leaks onto the low pressure side above the wing. (It's an oversimplification, but it mostly works.) This finite wing effect is associated only with the tip of a long wing; Flow around sections of a wide span wing near the root behaves a lot more like ideal wing section flow than flow close to the tips.

This leakiness does a couple of bad things, and at least one not-so-horrible thing. First, it reduces the coefficient of lift for the span as compared to the wind tunnel flow. Second, it gives rise to induced drag, which is that rotationally energized flow leaving the wing tips (plus the fact that your reduced lift coefficient means you have to pitch higher, basically aiming more of your lift aft). Third, and the good(ish) bit, is that it mushes out the stall, at the expense of a lower stall angle of attack. (It's nice when stalls happen gradually, with warning, rather than suddenly.)

Those raised wing tips you see are a compromise between parking and performance. They are about 2/3 as effective as they would be if they were horizontal extensions of the wing.

Notice that I'm talking here about span, and not aspect ratio. Aspect ratio, pointedly, is not a substitute for span. If you doubled a wing's width, you would get no reduction in benefit from doubling its chord length as well, other than a possible weight penalty, or the skin friction drag to which I think you allude. As they say on Monty Python, "SPAN! SPAN! SPAN! SPAN!..."

The one exception to this is very light craft at very low wing loadings, like RC sailplanes. (So-called "floaters.") Down there, the lift, and therefore induced drag, is so low that the parasitic drag begins to dominate, and you can choose an "optimum" span for a given flight weight. I forget the paper where I saw the derivation of that.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by phumbe on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:57PM (#17122814)
Wing efficiency increases with the wing's aspect ratio, and the aspect ratio is the quotient of the span (b) squared and the area (S): b^2/S. So making the wingspan longer with relatively little increase in wing area increases efficiency.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by theothermkn on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:16PM (#17122905)
Span is actually the governing parameter. Aspect ratio is just a convenient parameter that grows with span if you conserve wing area. A wider wing with enough added planform area to have a lower aspect ratio would still outperform our theoretical shorter wing with higher aspect ratio.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by chiph on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:44PM (#17122752)
The shape probably comes into it - this wingtip sweeps upward at the end, so it can shed the vortex smoothly. Much like the wingtip airfoils you see on other current planes.