At some point though, these discounts are going to get deep enough to get me to put up with the WF crowds.
This is definitely a huge factor in the equation and just due to proximity. We live in close proximity to 6 grocery stores, 3 are the same brand. The store we choose to shop at comes down to selection because even among the 3 same branded stores the stock varies.
And that Kroger, just this week, did a partnership with ocado, which is the world leader in automation for grocery deliveries.
Groceries are like pizza. Pickup is a viable option because sometimes it is more convenient...twenty versus sixty minutes (hopefully) before eating.
But I would underestimate the value of pickup: from a point of view of a busy mom with 2 small kids, doing a grocery pickup is a much better experience, enough to be the differentiator that will determine to which store to go.
that isn't enough to disrupt but it is enough with a pliant press to make it seem you can. ALDI has 1600+ stores in 35 states and while its expected customers are more limited by means the appeal of ALDI does cover a lot of income levels.