Re:A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
by mjw1007 on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @03:55AM
(#17185889)
Quick summary of what happened next for anyone who comes across this thread in the future:
Under pressure from outside, the wikipedia admins decided to reopen this case. They fairly quickly came to consensus that Cross was violating the paragraph of the biography-of-living-persons-conflict-of-interest policy quoted above and banned him from editing Galloway's article.
There's continuing discussion of whether Cross is doing anything more seriously wrong.
Re:A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
by tptacek on Saturday May 19, 2018 @05:44PM
(#17109888)
A biased point of view isn't a conflict of interest. See:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest...?
We all have biases. But we have conflicts when we have direct relationships with topics.
Similarly: edits are supposed to have NPOV. But editors almost always have a POV.
(Unless "don't criticise a top-1000 user" counts as a Wikipedia norm, I suppose.)
I disbelieve that that the admin in question is both a neutral arbiter and capable of determining within two minutes that Cross is not an "avowed rival" of Galloway (see WP:BLPCOI), particularly given the "And being attacked by RT and George Galloway is a reasonably reliable indicator that you are doing something right" bit on his talk page.
[The relevant part of BLPCOI is:
« Therefore, an editor who is involved in a significant controversy or dispute with another individual—whether on- or off-wiki—or who is an avowed rival of that individual, should not edit that person's biography or other material about that person » ]