News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by bmelton on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:57AM (#17108118)
> It can play with the structure to make the shows work better for its ad-free format

I think people underrate how big this is from a creator perspective. As viewers, we typically appreciate when work is uninterrupted by commercials (though some shows are more forgiving of them than others), but to my understanding, it's quite difficult as a creative to segment your work out into 12-14 minute segments, constantly building up enough momentum that people will be riveted through the commercial long enough to stick around, and then having to ensure enough recap is done after the break that it doesn't break the narrative flow.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by magicalhippo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:18AM (#17108211)
This is one of the reasons I prefer Netflix-only shows, where the episodes aren't filled with contrived cliffhangers just for the sake of trying to hang on to viewers during ad breaks.

Instead episodes usually feel much more like short movies, with proper pacing and reveals.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by christoph on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:36AM (#17108289)
Something I'm glad they've taken advantage of is having episodes in a series with totally different runtimes - e.g. Master of None, episode lengths range between 22 mins & 58 mins. It really frees up the writing & directing to have more room to breathe.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by noir_lord on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:15PM (#17108470)
For me it's the 5 minute recap, 5 minute content, 5 minute break, 5 minute recap loop on most shit.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by c22 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:21PM (#17108769)
They just stick the contrived cliffhangers on the end of each "episode" instead.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by ejstronge on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:29PM (#17108807)
Episode-ending cliffhangers are present in almost all television shows. Netflix hasn't led to an increase in these, in my cursory experience.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by c22 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:52PM (#17108900)
No, but I have found the ones in Netflix shows to be more banal, with even cross-season cliffhangers resolving with low import to the plot.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by sametmax on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:28PM (#17109064)
That's today's shows in general. Lots of build up to something the writers either haven't an idea how to resolve yet or just over hyped.

As photography and CGI improved, writing went down the toilet. Mainly because it's not necessary to make money. Most viewers are happy enough for bad plots, so-so acting, dubious congruency and limited dialogs as long as it's visually entertaining.

As usual, the wider your audience, the duller your product has to become to accommodate everyone.

The worst is definitely dubbing. In France you can clearly see that around 2000, producers gave up any effort on looking for decent translator and voice actors. The voices are always the same from one movie to another, the lips don't match, the jokes are lost.

When I watch the 5th element or the naked gun however, I'm amazed at the fantastic work they did to translate the spirit of the lines so beautifully.

Still, sometimes on netflix you got some very nice surprises, provided you watch it in orginal version only. "The good place" and "Dirk gently" really made my day.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:04PM (#17109227)
I've been watching "Babylon Berlin" on Netflix which is pretty good. But I was annoyed at the dubbing, it just felt out of place.

I finally found a switch to switch to the German soundtrack with English subtitles. I'm much happier with that.

I wonder why each scene is not just shot twice, once with the German dialog and once with English. It would work much better than dubbing.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by paholg on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:25PM (#17110494)
> I wonder why each scene is not just shot twice, once with the German dialog and once with English.

Because this would require an exclusively bilingual cast, dialog that works equally well in both languages, and would drastically increase the production cost.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:40PM (#17110697)
> an exclusively bilingual cast,

Not really. First off, most Germans seem to know English passably well. Even if one doesn't know English well, one can still memorize/recite dialog. There isn't that much dialog in a show. And lastly, one can always dub the ones who can't do it, as a last resort.

> dialog that works equally well in both languages,

A requirement anyway if it is being dubbed.

> and would drastically increase the production cost

Increase it, sure, not so sure about drastically. Why spend a lot of money on the production (as is obvious in Babylon Berlin) only to make it sound crappy to the biggest market (English speaking)? An English soundtrack makes it accessible to most of the world.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by greedo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @07:09PM (#17110224)
It's not just a matter of shooting it 2x. It's a matter of getting the scene right the second time. Each final shot that makes it in has many that don't. In contrast, dubbing is relatively cheap.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by sametmax on Saturday May 19, 2018 @05:30PM (#17109836)
Because that's super expensive. Just bless netflix for always providinh original version and subtitles.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Saturday May 19, 2018 @06:56PM (#17110174)
I don't see why. Multiple takes are often done anyway. The setting is all there, the actors in place, the lighting - just do another take. It doesn't have to be done for all the scenes.

I also wonder why the original actors didn't do the dub voices.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by nighthawk1 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:00AM (#17111318)
If you ever did acting before you would understand how difficult it is to get a scene just right and how misguided your statement is.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:21AM (#17111371)
Nope, I've never done any acting. But Director Clint Eastwood has a reputation for "one take" and seems to disagree with you:

"Everybody's heard those nightmare stories of somebody doing a take 20, 30, 40 times. Other than obvious errors like forgetting a line, often I can't see any difference between take one and take 20."

https://www.dga.org/Craft/DGAQ/All-Articles/0309-Sept-2003/C...

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by p49k on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:50AM (#17111573)
That’s great that Clint Eastwood personally prefers that style, but that doesn’t make it universally true nor does it mean that other directors would have the same results with one take. The negative effects of stifling a director by placing this artificial constraint would probably counteract any positives of having two versions.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by nighthawk1 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:46PM (#17113606)
Agreed. All the directors I have worked with have required multiple takes for certain scenes. The cost of an additional take is small and the reward of a better shot greatly outweighs that cost.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:45PM (#17114178)
> The cost of an additional take is small

Exactly my point!

> the reward of a better shot greatly outweighs that cost

My point, too, the "better shot" being the improvement of the lips and voice matching the movement and action. Consider that the English language market is most of the world.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by nighthawk1 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @08:04PM (#17115411)
I get what you are saying but to retake a well shot scene in order to have a better dubbing experience doesn't make sense. I encourage you to make a film to test your idea, though :)
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Sunday May 20, 2018 @08:56PM (#17115549)
> doesn't make sense

I've seen it done, don't recall which movie it was.

> make a film

I'd love to do that. Wanna finance me?

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by meowface on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:05AM (#17125986)
I think that's just because Netflix has a fair number of pretty bad shows (as any other network does). This isn't an issue with well-written shows.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by new299 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:25PM (#17108524)
Overall, I think it's a positive change. But I think there are other effects too.

One is the trend toward longer, multi-season story arcs. This is also a trend in traditional television, but seems that the single episode story is dead on Netflix.

That's a shame, because it often is possible to succinctly express an idea in 30mins or 1hour. But it's in Netflix's best interests to keep you hooked on a show and "watching one more episode". That's particularly valuable for content that is released week-by-week. It also has other benefits, the more you watch, the more you're dependent on their service.

The one exception to this I've seen on Netflix is Black Mirror. But that was a show developed outside of the platform initially. I can't see something like Star trek the next generation, or another idea driven show which explores a single idea in a single episode being green lit on Netflix, and that's a shame.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by wvenable on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:58PM (#17108939)
> But it's in Netflix's best interests to keep you hooked on a show

Is it? For Netflix the more the watch, the more it costs them. The only thing they want is to keep you subscribed and that's an entirely different sort of motivation.

Traditional TV is focused on selling eye-balls to advertisers; keep you hooked on a show is necessary. For Netflix, they just have to ensure the entire service provides enough value that you'll continue to pay monthly for it.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by new299 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @08:11AM (#17112408)
I would be surprised if this wasn't an internal metric that the optimize for. I'd be surprised if a drop in viewing time didn't strongly correlate with cancelled subscriptions (which they use as motivation).

When a film ends, they always seem to play a trailer for something else (even if you've seen that trailer 10s of times already). They seem to want to push content at you.

As noted elsewhere in the thread, they seem to see their competition not just as traditional TV, but as other ways of spending time.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by lifeisstillgood on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:31PM (#17109341)
That's a fantastically insightful point - i suspect that Netflix has not truly grasped it either
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by 1123581321 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:33PM (#17111047)
We know Netflix doesn’t believe that measurement is good for their company because they spend as much as possible on content and give creators more control than traditional publishers to make the content better.

They also talk about their competition being sleep, games, YouTube, etc.

These aren’t the actions of a company that wants to give users “just enough.”

I think the only time they’d apply this idea (the only place it’s appropriate, IMO) is when reaching the limits of their budget and prioritizing one market over another. In that case it would make sense to avoid dropping below a threshold of attention. However, as in the article, they do what they can to make content watchable in all markets at once so they don’t have to take that risk.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by eslaught on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:01PM (#17108679)
Speak for yourself. In my opinion, this is a massive win for storytelling. And I'm saying this as a lifelong Star Trek fan who has watched every single series end-to-end except for TOS.

As much as I love it, Star Trek feels old. And this is the #1 reason why. With relatively small exceptions, every episode is complete disconnected from every other. The beginning of the episode sets up some sort of problem or danger. By the end of the episode, this danger is dealt with, gone. Character development is either non-existent, or happens at such a painfully slow pace that it's difficult to feel connected to what's going on. Instead what we see (if anything) are "snapshots" into the character's mental state. This is simply not how you tell a good story! So it's not surprising to me that Star Trek went fallow for a long time.

The point about character development applies to the universe too. People like to say that the Federation feels old. But what they really mean, in my opinion, is that the Federation should be viewed as a character. And if you think about it that way, it becomes obvious that as a character, the Federation is completely missing character development. So it's no wonder people get tired of it! Would you want to read a novel about a character who doesn't change at all during the course of the story? Would you come back for more after a half dozen of these?

The problem with saving the world perfectly every time is that over the long term, this means there is no change. Every individual episode might be a great story, but at the end of the day, did any of it matter? If there are no permanent consequences, it's hard to see how. This becomes especially obvious if you binge-watch the shows. Everything is always the same. Nothing changes.

What I want to see in a show (Star Trek or otherwise) is change. Permanent, irrevocable change. You dropped a glass, and it shattered, and no amount of wishing otherwise will put it back together again. That doesn't mean you can't do something about it! But certainly, you're not just going to put things back into exactly the same state they were before.

P.S.

You might be tempted to say, "oh, but what about DS9?" But even there, the format was largely unchanged. Go and count the episodes. The ones that actually dealt with any sort of ongoing story are a minority. Most of the shows follow the same framework as previous series. Except for one 10-episode sequence at the very end, you can basically forget that the war exists between the episodes that they mention it.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by c22 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:33PM (#17108827)
Binge-built tv shows are definitely great for storytelling, over the last 15 years or so I've found feature length films to be severely lacking in depth compared to the development that can happen over untold hours of serialized tv. There is something to be said for the isolated narrative format, though. I appreciate that I can watch any random Star Trek without refreshing my understanding of the plot or getting sucked into the next episode. I wonder if this format would be used in more Netflix shows if Netflix had a random button.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by new299 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:30PM (#17108808)
I'm not saying it's an either/or proposition. I think it's great to see characters develop over as they encounter different situations and the long term implications of their actions.

But I think it's also interesting to sometimes explore idea in a shorter period of time... I don't think there's much space for that anymore. And sometimes that can explore certain ideas more succinctly.

You mention DS9, I think a few characters developed in quite interesting ways over the course of the series actually Dukat and Kai Winn for example.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by mixmastamyk on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:10PM (#17109247)
Believe what you’re looking for is Babylon 5, which pioneered the story arc twenty years before Netflix.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by rainbowmverse on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:17PM (#17109282)
The alleged (last I checked) Deep Space 9/Babylon 5 scandal is interesting to read about. Good starting point: https://www.reddit.com/r/babylon5/comments/7qbjn7/did_deep_s...
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by siidooloo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:36PM (#17108835)
The quality of TV writing has definitely improved in recent years. But we a have a new problem now. The producers still want the shows to run forever. Instead of telling discrete stories and wrapping them up in a season or two they try to keep stringing the audience along. The characters end up repeating the same situations.

Rather then one series that runs for 5 to 10 years I’d prefer 2 or 3 different series telling different stories about the same characters. A few crime series have been dealing with one case person. I’d like to see more things like that.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by greedo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @07:14PM (#17110243)
There are some stories on Netflix that are single season, or single show. I just watched Anon, it was fine as a single show. A single season show like "The End of the F*ing World" is perfect, and true to its source material.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by TillE on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:39PM (#17108586)
For all the gloss of "prestige TV", a lot of the big story arc shows are basically just modern soap operas.

I think that'll slowly change though, because the current trend seems primarily motivated by culture rather than structure or economics. Like, procedural shows are still big, but they were everything for a few years after CSI. These things come and go.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by dsr_ on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:17PM (#17109283)
People like soap operas, if by that term you mean long stories about the relationships of a family-to-tribal size group of interesting people.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by hrktb on Sunday May 20, 2018 @05:00PM (#17114696)
Netflix is helping produce a bunch of anime recently, and from that point of view it doesn’t seem to have a single focus on genre or format.

It looks more like a “we’ll pay you to make stuff people want to watch” approach, with no specific request on “high brow” or “low brow” or overall length.

In a way I think they don’t care if a creator or studio makes 4 different series where 2 are big hits and 2 with a meh reception, or one big 4 season series where viewers drop out a random places.

As long as viewers come back to Netflix to look for more stuff it should be fine for them.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by chickenfries on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:16PM (#17108743)
Once nice counter example to this is Black Mirror, which I think really benefits from being completely episodic.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by AndrewUnmuted on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:21PM (#17108512)
I think it is misleading to label Netflix as being an ad-free distributor. They in fact do generate revenue via advertising - it's just more modern and hidden: product placement.

"According to Isaacs, brands pay $50,000 to $500,000 per episode for getting into a Netflix or Amazon show. The price is calculated based on the popularity of the show and how long the product will be showed in the episode. There are two options for product placement in the shows: a logo in the background or a real plot point in the story." [0]

This, to me, seems just as disruptive to the creative freedom of a program's producers/writers/directors.

[0] https://learnbonds.com/134772/netflix-killing-secret-ads-sho...

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by bmelton on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:37PM (#17108577)
It's probably unfair to refer to Netflix as ad-free, but (as I mention elsewhere), from a creator perspective, I'm referring more to the 'break-free' experience than 'ad-free'.

I do agree that impositions on the creative team to write in product placement are a hurdle, but I disagree on how difficult that hurdle is relative to literally stopping the show for a few minutes at a time, and from a consumer's perspective, product placement (when not overdone) is far less disruptive to the narrative than a commercial.

Of course, people discuss products in real life all the time, so it can be made to feel natural. Four Roses bourbon, TV shows like "Legion" and "Fargo", or Seagull Guitars could be product-placed into a TV show about my life and would look like just any other day in my life, for example.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by resu_nimda on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:56PM (#17109454)
One question though is what effect this has on shows with no plausible connection to contemporary life. Fantasy, historical, etc. Even in Legion a discussion involving brands would have to be pretty forced, though when they go out in public there's plenty of opportunity for logos (not sure if they used any placement or not, would be cool to see a database of this stuff).

Anyway it seems like there could be an increasing pressure against scripts that have no opportunities for brands.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by new299 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:27PM (#17108535)
Wow, I didn't know that. I guess it's logical given that it's been going on in TV/films for some time.

This is probably the end-game of Adblocking unfortunately. A lot more product placement that is obviously harder to filter.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by greedo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @07:16PM (#17110254)
I wouldn't be opposed to that; I just don't want malware/tracking running when I hit a website.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by untog on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:13PM (#17109003)
People need to bear this in mind more often. I recall watching the second (I think?) episode of Lost in Space the other day that absolutely crowbared in a placement for Oreo cookies, how great they are and how much they reminded the character of home.

It took me completely out of the show. I would honestly have preferred an isolated 30 second ad to that. It does still affect the creative process, too - your show needs to be one an advertiser wants to be placed on, so there's every incentive to soften the show.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by resu_nimda on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:37PM (#17109088)
I agree with you in principle about product placement affecting the integrity of the work, but what's funny is I didn't even think twice about that one.

Were there other products in the show? I remember looking for logos on the rovers and seeing none.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by greedo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @07:17PM (#17110258)
This is prevalent in movies as well. I just rewatched Terminator 2, and was amazed at how many Pepsi placements there were.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by jedberg on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:33PM (#17108561)
That’s on the show creators though. Netflix doesn’t see a dime of that money.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by AndrewUnmuted on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:47PM (#17108628)
It's true that the show's creators typically receive the cash for the product placement. (I also would guess that Netflix is getting a cut of some kind.)

Consider what it means that a service would optimize for this form of monetization. Brands that are placing products on Netflix shows are unencumbered by the brands/deals supported by other shows, since the product placement happens on the content level, instead of the distribution/broadcast level. Netflix can basically offer much more "robust" monetization options because its content choices don't narrow the scope and breadth of its list of supported brands.

One positive externality caused by the more limited advertising strategies employed by traditional broadcasters was that advertising was not a free-for-all. Ads were shown in predictable ways, on consistent (contractually-obligated) schedules. Now, Netflix can enable more and more next-generation advertising options within its content offerings, which is certain to lead to some disturbing changes. These changes would definitely catch its customers by surprise, if Netflix chose to roll out these strategies all at once. But they appear to be doing it slowly, so that most of their users will probably not notice it.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 20, 2018 @06:21AM (#17112123)
I've been seeing product placement from the traditional broadcasters well before Netflix came around.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by p49k on Sunday May 20, 2018 @02:54AM (#17111586)
The product placement in Netflix shows can be so jarring; I don’t understand how it could possibly be worth such a small amount to permanently damage your creative works.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by leetcrew on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:32PM (#17108558)
> This, to me, seems just as disruptive to the creative freedom of a program's producers/writers/directors.

only if there is a wide disparity in the price companies are willing to pay to have their product in the show.

say you have a show about a lawyer and they need a car to drive around in. my guess is bmw and mercedes offer similar amounts of money, so you just pick the one that the character would prefer.

on the other hand, you're probably not going to see anyone using a pixel 2 outside of mr robot.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by mmt on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:01PM (#17108952)
I've been noticing product placement for a long time[1], but the most jarring/disruptive product placement I've seen, at least in recent memory, is that of the Windows Phone, especially when every character in the show uses one. The UI is so distinctive, and they made such a point of showing it off. This was in more than one show. I have yet to see one being used by a real consumer.

[1] Listening to directors' commentaries on <ahem> laserdiscs "ruined" this bit of moviemaking for me early on

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by lifeisstillgood on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:42PM (#17109390)
How does one pay for a "plot point"? I can generally imagine how product placement works, but plot points seem a ever decreasing circle.

For starters the story needs to be set in modern day, and mostly modern western world. Cans of coke look out of place in Game of Thrones.

I can roughly imagine how you can get writers to create an embarrassing episode for Joey and Chandler over a Dunkin Donuts voucher, but the number of ways that can work well must be limited.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by qbrass on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:59PM (#17110934)
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by Reedx on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:12PM (#17108458)
Indeed, it has a huge impact on what writers can do. Content is shaped by the container it's in, and Netflix is a different kind of container.

No ads? Don't have to cater to advertisers, don't need to have advertiser friendly content.

No ad breaks? Don't need to create cliffhangers on a defined schedule. Can preserve flow.

On demand? Don't have to worry about people missing episodes.

No syndication? Don't have to worry about episodes being watched out of order. Now the world and characters can change in meaningful ways.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by wongarsu on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:33PM (#17108566)
It's also just so much wasted time. Once I started watching old Mythbusters episodes on youtube I realized that about a third of it is just drumming up suspense before a commercial break, or recapping after a break. That's time that could be filled with actually interesting content.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by evan_ on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:41PM (#17108595)
Fans have edited every mythbuster episode into “streamline” edits that get rid of all the recapping and precapping. They tend to be about 30-35 minutes long.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by kgwgk on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:32AM (#17108272)
As HBO or Showtime have done for decades.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by rainbowmverse on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:39AM (#17108298)
I had to stop watching The Walking Dead because of the endless commercial breaks. At least it reliably comes to Netflix. The spinoff, on the other hand, is missing the last season. I suspect it's because AMC is pushing their own streaming service with "watch the full current season now! Don't wait!"
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by headShrinker on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:49PM (#17108638)
Pretty sure almost everyone stopped watching The Walking Dead because of the continuous bad writing and lack of plot, boring interpersonal drama, constant death of interesting characters while the most boring characters get to linger like the stench of a mildew ridden towel.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by camgunz on Saturday May 19, 2018 @01:52PM (#17108899)
It's like they're so impressed with their messages (interesting people stand out, take risks and responsibility, and die, scarcity and fear are the reasons we made governments, humans are the real zombies, life is hard) they forgot to make a good show.

In fact I actually think they can't. Anyone remember season 2 where they tried to develop characters and what-not? It was agonizing.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:19PM (#17109291)
The characters never learned, either, which is why I quit watching. There was always "let's go to the village that we've never been to before, and split up so the zombies can take us out one by one!" among many idiotic tropes.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by thomastjeffery on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:13PM (#17109008)
I keep going back to it hoping that later seasons get better.

It had such a wonderful start...

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by FRex on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:09PM (#17109245)
The segmenting backfires hilariously between countries.

I've often seen shows go "It was Mr. X all along!", everyone looked at the person who said that in shock and awe and realization, there was a sound cue, screen faded to black and then the show continued with them going to kick Mr. X's teeth in, but already in a much less dramatic tone.

And then the actual break happens in another spot, where it's much less appropriate and breaks the flow completely instead of making me eagerly await the end of the break to see Mr. X get his teeth kicked in.

This is actually a trope: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CommercialBreakCl...

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by tootie on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:33PM (#17108563)
That structure predates TV. Plays were divided into 3 or 5 acts.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by icebraining on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:03PM (#17108960)
They were divisions in the structure, but that's about the only similitude. Acts are an artistic choice, not an imposed constraint with defined timings and mandatory recaps.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by S_A_P on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:00AM (#17108133)
This times 100000000000000e100000
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by taeric on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:46AM (#17108339)
I think you overrate how big this is from a creator perspective. In large, because it is a return to previous standards, in many ways. Large chunks of content are not a new thing. If anything, the ads that we take for granted are somewhat the new flash in the pan. And like most flashes, pretty sure they flared out.

No, Netflix has managed to keep the requirement that a studio needs a ton of cash to produce something.

Youtube, on the other hand, probably has done a lot to change television. Shame it is changing back.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by ebbv on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:28AM (#17108244)
The thing is it's kind of a false narrative. Because the shows aren't entirely ad free. They're mostly ad free, but Lost in Space for example featured an extremely jarring product placement for Oreos which came up repeatedly in an episode. It was just as jarring for me as ad placements, disrupting the narrative and throwing me out of the story. Especially since hte Oreo package was identical to the ones we have now even though the show is supposedly decades in the future.

This happens in most Netflix shows; jarring and obvious product placement that disrupts the flow of the story.

So it's not that they are ad free, they just featured reduced ads in most episodes.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by ljm on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:54PM (#17108649)
Some product placement can be cheesy no matter what situation it's in but I'd take a few moments of cheesy product insertion over the typical pattern of a US serial: 2 seconds of blackness (or 3 minutes of commercials) every 12 minutes or so, 20 minutes of story time traded for adverts, and dialog you would never encounter in a more continuous story because it assumes the audience is intelligent enough to figure it out or start from the beginning. It's mind-numbing in the extreme.

Bringing up a pack of Oreos and waving it around the screen so everybody can really see it's a pack of Oreos is one thing, but the endless trudge of scenes like this is something else:

X: "So you got the brief from the NSA?"

Y: "The National Security Agency, they monitor all the communications in the US to prevent terrorism... yes I got the brief. You bring in Mr Snucklebum for questioning?"

X: "Snucklebum, the man under suspicion for trading classified secrets? Yeah he's in interrogation, right through here."

- alarm bells, ad break -

Y: "Snucklebum's escaped! Lockdown!"

X: "Snucklebum, the guy under suspicion for trading classified secrets to the NSA?"

Y: "The national security agency. Yeah"

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by rootlocus on Saturday May 19, 2018 @04:27PM (#17109588)
I've always admired a show that can explain the plot and setting without characters having to say obvious, out of character, things to each other. Black Mirror is one such show.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by bmelton on Saturday May 19, 2018 @05:29PM (#17109828)
Lazy exposition is a plague in the industry, and is pretty prevalent in basically every broadcast show. CW and Lifetime shows tend to be the most offensive here.

There are a ton of shows that let you discover the show along with the characters though; Breaking Bad, The Wire, Carnivale, etc. Those shows tend to be well regarded, and most people don't realize that it's just the lack of exposition making the people pay attention that they like.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by WalterBright on Saturday May 19, 2018 @03:22PM (#17109300)
The first season of Miami Vice used a fake Ferrari Daytona. Ferrari got miffed about that, and offered them a real Ferrari Testarossa if they got rid of the fake Daytona. Hence, the characters blew up the Daytona and moved to the Testarossa.

It was a good year for Ferrari sales, too :-) The Testarossa was one of the stars of the show, and nobody minded it. Probably the best product placement ever!

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by bmelton on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:43AM (#17108320)
I'm not talking about ads, I'm talking about interrupting the show.

I don't know if the Oreos thing was a product placement (though it seems likely), but if I'm writing a script or a screenplay, I probably have fewer mental gymnastics to hurdle through to inject Oreos into a script than I do to have to accommodate a show-break.

On the flip side, it's worth pointing out that it isn't either/or, as shows with commercial breaks may still include product placement, and not all of them are going to be as mightily integrated as Snyder's of Hanover was to Psych.

Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by Fnoord on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:51AM (#17108361)
Movies have that as well though. Remember the Nokia in the original Matrix movie? It was slowed down for a second while it was thrown in a bin.
Re:Netflix is basically remaking all of TV now by Noos on Saturday May 19, 2018 @12:19PM (#17108497)
The Mighty Morphin Power Rangers movie has Krispy Kreme product placement to the point of absurdity, even having the main villain chowing down on one during the action.