Re:Tildes – A non-profit community site driven by its users'...
by Deimorz on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:33PM
(#17104303)
I think /r/ChangeMyView has a really good approach to this sort of thing (I'm using them as an example a lot here, but it's because I think they really do run one of the highest-quality communities on the internet).
One of their core rules is that people posting there have to demonstrate that they're open to having their opinion changed - they can't use the post just to soapbox. There's a lot written about it here, it's been very well thought-out: https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/wiki/rules#wiki_rule_b
Re:Tildes – A non-profit community site driven by its users'...
by mistermann on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:59PM
(#17104518)
Thanks, I've never really gone there before, sounds like maybe I should.
I will give a hopefully not too controversial example: tax policy.
I'd feel comfortable asserting (while standing in front of God at the entrance to the spirit world, so I must be honest) that well over 50% of people believe that <their person favorite economic policy> is(!) the "best way" to run a society, for <reasons> and <citations of "studies">. The reality though is, it is a matter of opinion, not of fact. And even if it was "objectively provable", that proof only holds under certain circumstances. The optimum policy varies based on the input parameters, which vary over time, but it also assumes we are all optimizing for the same thing!
Or in other words, the correct answer is very often: "it depends". You can see all sorts of people happily agreeing with this principle in their daily lives. How many people would get really, really angry if I said Vanilla is "the best ice cream flavor", or that "saving 25% of your net income is a wise strategy, if you can manage it". But wander into topics such as gender, sexuality, politics, etc and most of these very same people will become very emotional and illogical very, very fast.
If there was a site whose administrators were absolutely hardcore about not violating that principle (asserting that grey is white or black is not allowed, period, with penalty of a temporary or permanent ban), I think it could not only work, but if all the pieces fell together in the right way (with intelligent help and cooperation from admins/mods/users, and maybe even input from a broad spectrum of serious professional psychologists/sociologists/etc), it could change the world. I truly believe that.
EDIT: I'm kind of on the fence about whether this strict rule should be site-wide, or only in certain subforums, I could make an argument either way. I think it's fun to think about.
Also: I fully acknowledge I am one of the assholes I mention above. I'm an "asshole" because I actually believe ridiculously strongly about the importance of truth and logic (but also emotion), and that it matters more than almost anything. Literally millions of people die on a fairly regular basis because humanity can't get it's sh*t together on a handful of problems, most of which (but not all!) really aren't that complicated.