News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by ktta on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:27PM (#17096067)
I wouldn't be surprised if Intel came up with tools which help make use of the FPGA using higher languages like C.

Xilinx is already pushing it's Vivado HLx which is pretty much that. I'm not aware of Altera's current offerings but they won't overlook this so easily.

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by duskwuff on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:33PM (#17096119)
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by ktta on Thursday May 17, 2018 @06:18PM (#17096573)
Well there you go. So GP's concerns are largely addressed. Intel can just work on this tooling, and people who are going to use HDL are going to continue using them.
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by slivym on Friday May 18, 2018 @10:53AM (#17101929)
Good idea in theory, in practice it's a shit show. The current level of language support is "As long as you know how to write what you want in HDL, then you can write some C that uses custom pragmas and design patterns and attributes that will badly reproduce what you could have written in HDL in half the time".
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by slrz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:41PM (#17096201)
> I wouldn't be surprised if Intel came up with tools which help make use of the FPGA using higher languages like C.

These (almost by necessity) make you write code that doesn't look like any other C code. You can't just use some pre-existing C library and compile it to use FPGA resources. At that point, why not go a step further and just use a proper HDL?

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by imtringued on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:46AM (#17107679)
>At that point, why not go a step further and just use a proper HDL?

You're assuming that you're starting with an FPGA only project. In reality most projects that are going to be accellerated with these Xeon+FPGA systems is existing software where only a handful of hotspots will have be ported to the limited C language which is significantly less effort than rewriting the entire algorithm in HDL.

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by ktta on Thursday May 17, 2018 @06:20PM (#17096586)
Because although HDL doesn't look difficult syntax wise, it requires a very good understanding of logic gates. People need to pretty much take a course in digital design to be able to write something meaningful.

It took me a while to grok HDL and write working code (good, maintainable code aside) even though I took digital design courses.

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by SlowRobotAhead on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:02AM (#17099053)
HDL ISNT CODE.

FPGAs don’t get firmware.

HDL is a description of hardware.

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by ktta on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:00AM (#17099804)
There's no need for all caps.

HDL can be referred to as code. And I do know what HDL is and what FPGAs are, thank you.

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by SlowRobotAhead on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:43PM (#17102859)
>HDL can be referred to as code.

No, it can't. That's why the caps are there and I'm sticking to it. You basically justified it ;)

Code is something that you design to run sequentially. HDL is a description of gates and logic that runs all at the same time.

If you wanted to argue that the bitstream is firmware - that's a tougher discussion.

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by perl4ever on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:58PM (#17116031)
If code is inherently sequential, do you think that there is no such thing as "code" in functional programming languages?
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by aseipp on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:51PM (#17096303)
Intel recently released their own High Level Synthesis compiler for Quartus; like HLx, it's free and you can use it now on whatever device you want. You still have to do the interconnection to the CPU, if you have one.

Unlike Xilinx, though, Intel (very very recently) just started offering their OpenCL-for-FPGA SDK for free, and it works on most of their device families, including Arria/Xeon and Cyclone/ARM. I always found it disappointing that the OpenCL SDKs were normally licensed, since they're more-or-less a logical extension of HLS support. So that's nice of Intel.

They don't have any equivalent to Xilinx SDSoC though, but for datacenter targets they're shipping a different set of SDKs anyway (called "OPAE"), so maybe in the future they'll build something on top of the OPAE and OpenCL support (e.g. single-source model, like Sycl)

Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by typon on Thursday May 17, 2018 @05:48PM (#17096276)
Altera/Intel has had OpenCL support for years now
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by ktta on Thursday May 17, 2018 @06:15PM (#17096544)
OpenCL support is different from this.
Re:Intel Shows Xeon Scalable Gold 6138P with Integrated FPGA... by typon on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:00PM (#17097374)
Its a different approach to HLS. Arguably much better than the Vivado approach