Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by there on Monday September 20, 2010 @02:05PM
(#1709841)
ok, but how many comments are you losing because people don't want to fill out a captcha?
i've used defensio.com for filtering comments on my site with no captcha and rarely ever get a false positive or negative. false negatives are easy to spot, and users can manually override false positives by supplying an email address to get a confirmation link (which gets fed back to defensio as a false positive once clicked).
Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by jfager on Monday September 20, 2010 @02:33PM
(#1709959)
It's a tradeoff, sure. In my case, I'm perfectly happy to trade a few comments from people who don't want to deal with a captcha for never having to manually deal with spam. YMMV.
Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by mike-cardwell on Monday September 20, 2010 @03:07PM
(#1710098)
There are better ways of reducing comment spam to near zero without resorting to captchas. Here's how I did it:
https://secure.grepular.com/Blocking_Comment_Spam_Using_ModS...
It's still working now.
Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by mseebach on Monday September 20, 2010 @03:31PM
(#1710203)
That's great, pretty much any home-rolled CAPTCHA will perform great, simply because it's not worthwhile for spammers to design an attack. If that, however, was the default anti-spam mechanism on, say, wordpress installs, it'd be automated against in minutes.
Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by mike-cardwell on Monday September 20, 2010 @04:04PM
(#1710326)
Definitely. If more people rolled their own, the spammers would be screwed.
Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by il on Monday September 20, 2010 @01:39PM
(#1709730)
That's one datapoint. The counterpoint is the thousands of forum owners who mistakenly relied on captcha to prevent spam at the expense of other antispam measures, like GeoIP.
Re:Goodbye (Crummy) CAPTCHAs. Hello Ad Dollars?
by jfager on Monday September 20, 2010 @01:54PM
(#1709793)
I'm not saying captchas are a magic one-step solution to end all spam (hence the mention of Akismet). I'm just disputing the idea that they are "nothing more" than illusory security. Sure, they can be turked, and sure, if someone relies only on captchas they'll probably eventually get screwed. But they do provide some benefit as part of a complete approach against spam, in that they raise the cost of a spam attempt up from zero. Unless you have meaningful levels of traffic, the vast majority of spammers aren't going to bother with you if it costs anything at all to hit you.
Then I installed reCaptcha, and now Akismet catches ~10 a month, and I've had to manually flag zero.
I'll take that illusion, thanks.