This was later, awesomely riffed on by HotCaptcha (http://valleywag.gawker.com/246656/a-face-only-a-bot-could-l...) which pulled HotOrNot data and asked you to select the 3 hot women out of 9. Sadly, the site is down now but I remember trying it and it was remarkably useful and a hell of a lot more fun than word captchas.
Specific ads may be in circulation for a short time, or there may be many running concurrently, but it is the message that the advertiser is trying to get across, the tagline, and it would be of most benefit to the advertiser to get the user to associate their brand with a single concept. Using the example in the article, Subaru may want to be associated with "outback", not "four wheel drive" or "comfy" or "sporty". Businesses who try to target too many things or too wide an audience end up not getting their message across.
I'm not saying that what Solve Media is trying to do isn't a great idea. I think it has lots of potential, but they clearly still have more to work on.
> show a picture of an animal or a shape and ask what it is,
Ok, so let's say you come up with pictures of 20 different animals. A spam script that picks the same answer every time will have a 5% success rate.
> or even just ask a simple math problem or riddle in writing.
Computers are way better at solving most math problems than people.
Please be careful. It could be that his thoughts are excellent but his communication is flawed. It could also be that he has a great deal of general expertise in the subject but is mistaken in this specific statement.
Thus, a general statement about him could be false is also aggressively ad hominem. You might want to consider focusing on the statement itself rather than the speaker, such as:
"Your suggestion is entirely wrong."
JM2C of course, and it is possible that I don't know what I'm talking about. I am not a psychologist or a logician.
If you display 10 random animals (or shapes), and ask a user to pick the right one, a dumb spam script would have a 10% success rate.
If you display one image of an animal and give 10 possible answers, a dumb spam script would have a 10% success rate.
What if I combine three pictures in each challenge - e.g. "cat house triangle"?
Plus you constantly have to update your image library, which a huge pain.
Also, recognizing 10,000 images will take me around one day and less than $1000 with Amazon turk, thus giving me a perfect 100% success rate. After that you would have to completely renew your image database.
YES, it would be a pain to update the library, which is why I'm commending this particular concept for solving that problem ...
If you present 10 images (still a stretch), bots will have 10% success rate just answering randomly.
EDIT: Wait, from what I see you mean that the user will have to write "cat" or "dog" or whatever? That's better, yes. Communication, however, is hard, which is why me the GP didn't understand what you meant.
Problem with those are that they need to be constantly updated from a reliable source, or else, once the solution becomes popular, the spammer can bruteforce it in linear time (no matter how high N is, there are only N possible patterns).
This seems to be an attempt at fixing this. Ads are often relatively short lived so by the time the spammer has them bruteforced, it might be out of circulation - and more importantly, there are new ads in. It's an armsrace, and this is a way to pay our troops. Also, it's trivial for advertisers to make many different variations (e.g. one for each sales bulletpoint), so there are many variations in circulation. Since there's often more textual content than the password in the ad, they're not prone to simple OCR, while still easy to comprehend for the user.
Obvious shortcomings are if ads are not so shortlived, and if it's easy to identify and break classes of ads (e.g. if it's yellow and has the IE logo in position X, OCR area Y, done). Also, it's a bit of a dealbreaker if I'm forced to open and visit a website to get the password.