News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Run a Blockchain on a Deserted Island with Pen and... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:56AM (#17082894)
> Well if he’s the strongest of the bunch, he could simply impose on the group and say “this is a new consensus rule, accept it or else”. So much for decentralized consensus!

Isn't this always the case? If Hugo is strong enough, he can also bully his way into abandoning the blockhain, and relying on his word for what everyone's balance is.

(Of course, this kills any notion of an actual economy, and becomes a totalitarian regime powered by effectively slave labor...)

Re:How to Run a Blockchain on a Deserted Island with Pen and... by hudon on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:25AM (#17083142)
> Isn’t this always the case?

Well yea, that’s how societies work. Social hierarchies emerge as we delegate power to the strong and wise. If they abuse their power, there is strife and potentially war, and eventually the corrupt leader gets replaced with a new one.

The idea that Bitcoin or any given blockchain is “more decentralized” than what we currently have is profoundly flawed. All you have to do to control a blockchain is control its consensus rules, as the Hugo example demonstrates. All you have to do to control the consensus rules is control the developers... and developers don’t operate in some parallel universe outside of our governments’ control.

All that to say, yes indeed, Hugo runs the show here, blockchain or not... just like he runs the show in the real world.