News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eigenvectors and Eigenvalues (2015) by aje403 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:44AM (#17074829)
This is frightening but believable. I've worked with a few "quants" who stared at me doe eyed explaining eigen* and basic calculus concepts to them in the context of why their calculations don't add up. You mention you've used fourier transforms before - if you don't understand an eigenbasis then you don't have a fundamental understanding the math you're deploying.
Re:Eigenvectors and Eigenvalues (2015) by ajross on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:27PM (#17079057)
> You mention you've used fourier transforms before - if you don't understand an eigenbasis then you don't have a fundamental understanding the math you're deploying.

That's a bit uncharitable. A fourier decomposition can absolutely be understood as an explicit bag of calculus tricks, with no loss of precision or generality. And an awful lot can be done with just those tools -- you don't need to explain JPEG compression or VLBI astronomy in terms of eigenvectors, for example.

Obviously (heh, "obviously") it's true that the space of decomposed functions form an orthogonal basis, so technically we're "really" operating in a linear space and that has expressive power too. But there are lots of ways of looking at problems.

To wit, you're not wrong. You're just... Well, you know.

Re:Eigenvectors and Eigenvalues (2015) by aje403 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @05:26AM (#17081034)
Dude your post is orthogonal
Re:Eigenvectors and Eigenvalues (2015) by xevb3k on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:16PM (#17075614)
In the context I used it, FFT wasn’t really of fundamental importance. Using FFT (and in particular FFTW) gave a performance improvement (execution speed), but no real advantage in terms of accuracy over an alternative naive method...

So... yes I guess I’ve just not seen anywhere in my work where this stuff has proved useful...

Re:Eigenvectors and Eigenvalues (2015) by aje403 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:29PM (#17075758)
It's pretty much ubiquitous in any quantitative field... would not even know where to start