News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:50AM (#17073885)
So because you think that Apple isn't listening to your needs, you can take the OS that they created and use it however you want to?

I am honestly surprised at how many people in this thread don't seem to care about Apple's right to decide how people use the software that they licensed from Apple.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by shortformblog on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:28AM (#17074128)
This site is called Hacker News, right? Certainly, taking a piece of hardware I own and making it do something it was not designed to do properly fits the description of "hacking," right?

I appreciate Apple's value as a company as much as the next guy, but this was not a decision made lightly. If they want $100 from me over the right to run their OS on my computer (as I believe they used to charge during the PowerPC days), fine. But their failure to give consumers the option, in this and so many other cases, highlights a big frustration longtime users have with the company nowadays.

I'm sure Apple knows about the Hackintosh community, and I'm sure they follow it. I also know they have done little to stop it. As a user, I want them to care about my needs as much as they do about their bottom line. They used to.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:36AM (#17074201)
I understand that people are usually driven to build a hackintosh out of frustration with Apple's hardware offerings.

That doesn't change the fact that it's against their licensing agreement. Anyone who wants to be able to sell their software in the future (or write software for a company that sells software) should care about that and have good reasons for violating it if they choose to do so. Many people in this thread seem to accept that it's a morally okay thing to do without thinking about it at all.

The site may be called Hacker News but it's full of mainstream software developers, many of whom work for companies like Apple. It's also (as far as I know) always been more focused on the startup scene than the hacking scene. You would think that people who's goal is to build their own business would care about this sort of thing.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by Hamuko on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:39AM (#17074225)
Our software business is not dependent on shrink-wrap EULAs and neither is Apple's.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by patrickg_zill on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:41PM (#17079627)
HN is an international community. In Germany for instance, Apple's EULAs are not the same as in the USA, and installing on a hackintosh is not a violation under German law, IIRC.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by shortformblog on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:40AM (#17074232)
I'm not a software developer, I'm a technology enthusiast.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by xkcd-sucks on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:12PM (#17076815)
a "disgruntled customer"
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by Hamuko on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:54AM (#17073914)
I care as much as Apple does, which is to say, not at all.

I got my license fair and square out of Apple's App Store with the purchase of a Mac. I then put it on a flash drive and installed it on another PC. Didn't fail any license check whatsoever since Apple has no interest in making any.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:57AM (#17073929)
It's right there in section 2B of the EULA that you're only permitted to install it on Apple computers. Why would they put that in there if they didn't care?

https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/macOS1013.pdf

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by Hamuko on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:02AM (#17073958)
Why would they not implement a license key to macOS installation if they did care? iTunes EULA forbids users from developing missile weapons with iTunes, but I sincerely doubt that Apple actually cares about this fine point.

Also, as a document, macOS EULA is worth to me as much as a piece of toilet paper.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:08AM (#17074003)
So your stance is that companies have no legal right to decide how their software is used by those who license it? Their only option is to make such uses impossible?

That seems like a strange stance to take. Why shouldn't companies have legal protection over how their software is used? I can lease a car. Why not software?

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by tylerflick on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:18AM (#17074070)
Lease a car yes, but Ford has no right to tell you how to drive once you have purchased one of their cars.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:23AM (#17074095)
If I purchase a car from Ford, then yes, they have no right to tell me how to drive it.

If I lease a car from Ford, then they absolutely have a right to tell me how I can drive it. It's not my car - it's their car. Most car leases do stipulate how you can drive it. At the very least they have a restriction on the number of miles you can drive.

If someone has purchased a copy of MacOS from Apple, then I agree that they can do whatever they want with it. The thing is, no one purchases MacOS from Apple. They only lease it from Apple. That's why Apple has a right to decide how it's used.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by satsuma on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:49AM (#17074303)
there's a disconnect here though because ford offers you the option of direct purchase. you don't have that with macos. i'd be willing to bet people who use hackintosh would be willing to buy a key and do things the right way if apple offered, but they don't so they find alternatives. it's the same kind of argument used with media piracy: make something easy enough to buy and use legally, and people will spend money on it. make it convoluted and require hoops, and those same people will find workarounds
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:47AM (#17074848)
I'd be willing to bet on that too. I think offering a license key to put MacOS on whatever hardware you want would be really popular. I'd probably buy one myself.

That said, convenience is a good argument for why things like media piracy and hackintoshes happen but not an argument at all for whether or not those actions are morally justified.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by Hamuko on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:44AM (#17083303)
I don't have a fiber in me that feels bad about having a Hackintosh. I'm an Apple customer. There's two MacBooks in my home. And going by the poll on tonymacx86 [1], >60% of the voters do own a Mac. Why would Apple want to come after these people, apart from legal trademark protection faffing?

I'd say I have more of an incentive to buy a Mac if I can run it on all of my computers. If I ran a Linux distribution on my desktop, I'd buy a nice Windows machine and load it with the same OS.

The problem is that Apple does not sell the hardware that I and a lot of people want to have. I think I paid around 1000 euros for my computer in raw parts. I think I could pay like 1400 euros for a same kind of machine if it had an Apple logo on the side and had guaranteed updates, which my computer doesn't. But I can't pay that. I can't even pay double to get that kind of a computer. It doesn't exist.

[1] https://www.tonymacx86.com/threads/do-you-own-a-real-mac.59/

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by Plasmoid2000ad on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:24AM (#17074613)
If Ford switched from selling cars, to only leasing cars... and there was any sort of lock-in to a Ford ecosystem, you would have something pretty similar.

If Apple wants to claim it leases MacOS with the sale of a Mac, that's fine but it's horrible anti-consumer and If they ever attempted to enforce it, i'd expect legislation to knock it back. It's probably already unenforceable in much of the world.

If it's truly a lease, it should also have a time limit when it reverts ownership back to Apple... surely otherwise it's just a one-off payment for permanent rights to use MacOS.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:45AM (#17074836)
But on what principles would the legislation be based? You can't just declare something anti-consumer and call it a day. Apple charging more than other companies for their computers can be considered anti-consumer - should that be illegal too?

The point of legislation and regulation in this instance would be to balance the needs/desires of both the consumers and the company. Saying that Apple's only option is to give consumers full rights to do anything with their software goes too far in the direction of the consumer in my opinion.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by abiox on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:07AM (#17074474)
this comparison isn't particularly interesting, because you're comparing dissimilar things. a leased car is a physical item that has inherent costs in manufacturing and distribution. bits have asymptotically zero cost there. a leased car has to be recovered and released or sold. this doesn't apply to bits. etc.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by ksk on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @12:06PM (#17074975)
>this comparison isn't particularly interesting, because you're comparing dissimilar things

The differences are not relevant to the point - which is the concept of ownership versus leasing.

>bits have asymptotically zero cost there. a leased car has to be recovered and released or sold. this doesn't apply to bits. etc.

True, but I think you mean copying bits, not creating unique bit sequences.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by abiox on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:20PM (#17078416)
the "concept of ownership" is a bit too reductive given the contextual differences at play, because the context directly impacts practical matters like harm, customer autonomy, etc.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by abiox on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:01AM (#17074427)
virtual and physical items are rather distinct in nature, and comparing them is often useless.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by ksk on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:31AM (#17074690)
Why would you ever compare two items if they were identical?
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by abiox on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @12:07PM (#17074982)
why would you ignore category errors when comparing two items?
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by ksk on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @12:13PM (#17075043)
Because there is no agreed upon basis for you to claim a category error. Or at the very least, two reasonable people can agree that the basis of the classification is an opinion.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by abiox on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:22PM (#17078424)
sure, and understanding the category distinctions and how each person applies them leads being able to address things like wilsonnb's comment "That seems like a strange stance to take."
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by jasonlotito on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:07AM (#17073994)
> I am honestly surprised

Oh, sweet summer child. You have no idea. Welcome to HN, where this is the norm.

And don't for a second believe Apple hasn't benefited from this attitude in the past. Quite the contrary, some could make the argument that not caring about copyright helped bring Apple to where it is today.

Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by wilsonnb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:09AM (#17074007)
I'd like to hear that argument. My guess is that it has something to do with iTunes and music piracy but I'm not sure.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by ksk on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @11:29AM (#17074675)
Ive come to accept that nerds only care about copyright when its about GPL'd code, and not music/movies/proprietary software.
Re:Open source tutorial for Hackintosh installation by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:13AM (#17079972)
I could see how someone is more frustrated by theft from the commons than one of the wealthiest multinationals in the world.