News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Changing emotions with a word: The subtleties of semiotics by insickness on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @07:50AM (#17073258)
To have a political discussion without getting people too self-defensive, it's good to pose opinions in the third person:

"I support Trump because he's tough on immigration."

vs.

"People support Trump because he's tough on immigration."

Others are less likely to get combative when it seems like you are making an observation about a third party rather than planting a flag on a core belief.

Re:Changing emotions with a word: The subtleties of semiotics by germinalphrase on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @07:54AM (#17073276)
I work in an environment that requires me to have political/social conversations while also retaining my personal neutrality (I am not allowed to acknowledge personal beliefs).

I can second the usefulness of this approach. It goes a long a way toward keeping the discussion on the issue at hand and avoiding personal defensiveness.

Re:Changing emotions with a word: The subtleties of semiotics by awb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:01AM (#17073952)
That's always annoyed me with US politics. In the US politicians have a habit of saying "The American people..." Which immediately triggers my thought: "I'm an American person and I don't think that way".

The speaker seems immediately out of touch with me when they use the third person. However, when they use the first person and take responsibility for their own unique views, I can understand them better even if I don't agree.

Re:Changing emotions with a word: The subtleties of semiotics by haZard_OS on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @10:25AM (#17074106)
I agree with your point but I suspect the problem with statements like the one you identified is that they claim too much.

In other words, if I say "The American people want X", there are surely some Americans who don't want X and I just alienated them. If, however, I say "many Americans want X", I'm making a weaker claim that is easier to defend.

In general, I prefer that people err on the side of making a weaker claim. It's less frustrating to communicate with people willing to do so (for me, at least).

The one downside of criticizing "weasel words" is that more people start making overly broad claims that you and I do not care for.

Re:Changing emotions with a word: The subtleties of semiotics by kthejoker2 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:35AM (#17082234)
My favorite hedge is "The American people have spoken" whenever 350 or so adults with landlines answer a loaded question by saying they "somewhat agree."