Except they haven't used it in one product and a redesign. That is the standard archive icon on Android where it is used by a multitude of apps and millions of people daily.
Re:Gmail Icons are Hard
by wlesieutre on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:14PM
(#17071391)
Ah I haven't been on Android for a couple of years so I wasn't familiar with it. Having said that, I still think Apple's version is a clearer design.
That first part though, where I know what a bankers box is used for, really helps make the icon connect. I think this is important, but at the same time, it's difficult because it's not universal. The "floppy disk" save icon has already turned into an arbitrary symbol for younger generations, and I expect the bankers box is well on its way (if not there already). Maybe FBI evidence rooms in TV shows will help it hold out.
Floppy disk has an advantage because at least it's consistent across a ton of software. If you make up an icon and use it in one interface and then redesign that interface again in 4 years, you have a much harder time getting people to attach meaning to it consistently.
It's the visual equivalent of a text button with "Mloroab" on it. Yeah I speak English, but I don't know what that does.