The short answer is no, it's technically ZipCar that is insured and so from a personal capacity you have no car insurance if you only use ZipCars and don't run your own car (and personal insurance).
I'm not clear why that is a problem - you just loose your no claims bonus but surely that's reasonable?
Unfortunately not. In my experience, the slightest break in insurance coverage is an excuse to push you into the highest-risk pool. It's completely ridiculous. Perhaps the policy made sense before every piece of information relevant to insurance was tracked by computers, but now it seems like something that only exists to punish people who want to go car-free for awhile.
But there's far too many insurance companies around for them to phone everybody.
I've only held a license in the US for 2.5 years so that's probably why I pay $200/month for insurance!
Typically your rates are higher if you haven't been continuously insured over the past N years, where N is something in the range of 5-10.
(I've tried to ask this question of Zipcar representatives in the past, and no one has been able to give me an answer. Their FAQ on insurance doesn't help either: http://www.zipcar.com/how/faqs/one-faq?faq_number=28)