Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f...
by sykh on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:02AM
(#17065599)
Definitely there gray areas as you pointed out. My goal is to dissuade one from thinking that excessive punishment for crimes necessarily leads to less crime. It certainly dissuades some people but not everyone.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f...
by michaelt on Monday May 14, 2018 @02:21PM
(#17068020)
Oh, absolutely. People have been given 20+ year sentences for sub-$30 shoplifting [1,2,3] which is inexplicable if you think huge punishments will eliminate crime.
[1] http://articles.latimes.com/2001/jun/19/local/me-12244 [2] https://www.npr.org/2016/04/04/473004950/new-orleans-man-fac... [3] https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/cruel-and-unusual...
A spouse who kills after finds their partner in bed with someone else is what is traditionally called a 'crime of passion'. Maybe they would have committed that crime even if a policeman was looking over their shoulder.
A person who pockets a cell phone left unattended in a bar may be an equally spur-of-the-moment decision - but we wouldn't consider it a crime of passion. If a policeman was looking over their shoulder, they'd have resisted the impulse.
If people aren't being deterred from the second type of crime, we've got to ask whether the chance of being caught is too low, whether the punishment is too small, or whether the person isn't being rational about the expectation of punishment. Which probably varies from one crime to another.