Funnily enough, I had to send my smartphone in for repair recently, and I popped my SIM card back in my old Nokia phone that I'd kept in a drawer -- it works great. It's a 10+ year old device and the battery has lasted all week.

Yes, helped me skip the whole "attention drainage", "mobile detox", "missing the concern while looking at your screen", "stolen privacy" thing...

No, but my old one still works, unlike my last 8 smart phones.

And still you use the smart phones daily, not the 'working' Nokia.

It's not binary. Robustness is something we lost. Yes, I am more happy (maybe? Perhaps I now just have another way to waste my time and be interrupted) with my smartphone, but I (we) lost something in the transition. That's the point; you're adding complexity and some people want to pretend that there's no trade off.

I agree, there is always a trade-off, and it is good to make it as explicit as possible.